The Follow-up After Shorter Tapes Study. Effectiveness and Safety of Shorter Trans-obturator Tapes. (FAST)

Background:

Stress Urinary incontinence (SUI) is a frequent consequence of childbirth and affects 1/3 of the general female population. It gravely diminishes the quality of life of numerous women by limiting their ability to be physically active, and impairing their sexual function. Mid-urethral sling (MUS) procedures have been the dominant surgical treatment for SUI over the last two decades. The traditional MUS procedures places a polypropylene mesh for support under the urethra, either in front of the bladder passing through the pelvis to the lower abdomen (tension free vaginal tape (TVT)), or to the side of the pelvis in the groin area (tension-free vaginal tape obturator inside-out (TVT-O)). These traditional techniques have well documented long lasting results and have improved the quality of life in most women with SUI. However, a few women experience serious complications such as severe chronic pain, dyspareunia, erosion/expulsion of the mesh, and voiding dysfunctions. Even though these devastating complications are rare, the consequence for affected women is lifelong reduced quality of life, even if the synthetic material is removed in its entirety. This has led to massive negative publicity, lawsuits against manufacturers and a movement in social media to ban these procedures. Several countries have therefore reverted to older, less effective surgical methods to avoid the use of synthetic materials.

Single incision mini-slings (SIMS), with much less synthetic mesh than traditional slings were introduced worldwide in 2006. In 2010, the TVT-O Abbrevo (TVT-A), an intermediate sling, was introduced hoping to refine the clinical performance of shorter slings. SIMS and intermediate slings have shown promising short-term results, but regarding long-term efficacy and complication rates, there are only a few published studies with small sample sizes. Given that shorter slings could represent a middle ground between the risk of severe complications and a loss of life quality due to untreated urinary incontinence, data on long-term effect and safety of the newer shorter slings is urgently needed. Retrieving such knowledge would make it possible to update surgical guidelines and provide patients considering surgical options with evidence-based recommendations.

Since 1998, Norway has had a compulsory registry of all incontinence surgeries performed in the country, the Norwegian Female Incontinence Registry (NFIR). Akershus University hospitals (AHUS) started already in 2009 using the SIMS Ajust and later intermediate slings as their preferred incontinence procedure. We therefore have a unique possibility to study the long-term results and complication rates by inviting women back to a long-term follow-up having undergone SIMS and intermediate sling surgery at AHUS. This follow-up also provides the possibility of investigating sling position using 2D dynamic and 3D trans-perineal ultrasound (TPUS). AHUS has the expertise in advanced ultrasound within the research group. How positioning of intermediate slings under the urethra may affect long-term success rates and adverse events is largely unknown. This lack of knowledge makes it difficult for gynecologists evaluating patients in need of repeat surgery, due to either treatment failure or long-term complications. Understanding the biomechanical effects visualized by ultrasound of the increasingly popular shorter slings would enable researchers and doctors to develop the treatment techniques for female incontinence further.

Research questions and methodology:

Part 2. Our over-all aim is to evaluate long-term subjective and objective outcomes of shorter slings.

Study design: Prospective observational study Long-term subjective outcomes Study population: Women treated with SIMS Ajust (n = 744) at Akershus University Hospital between 2009 and 2016 and Intermediate sling TVT-A (n= 318) at Akershus University Hospital between 2016 and 2020.

Follow-up: Potential study participants for both groups will be identified in the local quality database for female incontinence surgery (local NFIR) at AHUS and invited to a long-term follow-up (4-14 years) with questionnaires. The following questionnaires will be sent electronically to the patients together with study invitation and consent form: The validated NFIR questionnaire, the validated Pelvic Floor Impact Questionnaire (PFIQ-7) as well as additional questions regarding pain.

Primary outcomes: Long-term subjective cure rate. Secondary outcomes: Long-term treatment satisfaction scores, quality of life score and complication rates.

Long-term objective outcomes Study population: The 318 women having been treated with the currently most used shorter sling (TVT-A) at AHUS between 2016 and 2020 will be invited to a physical follow-up were they will undergo a clinical examination including assessment of objective cure, sling erosions and development of pelvic organ prolapse using the POP-Q system.

Primary outcomes: Long-term objective cure rates. Secondary outcomes: The same as defined under 1) Long-term subjective outcomes.

Part 3. We will study the positioning of the shorter sling TVT-A under the urethra using dynamic 2D and 3D ultrasound.

Our aim is to study the association between sling position, tension and anchoring under the urethra, and subjective and objective cure rate, and long-term complication rates, especially chronic pelvic pain.

Study design: Prospective observational study Study population: 318 women having had surgery with the intermediate sling TVT-A at AHUS between 2016 and 2020.

Follow-up: Women who consent to study participation and attend the physical follow-up will undergo a clinical examination that includes a transperineal ultrasound (TPUS) examination in the dorsal lithotomy position using a 3,5-6 MHz curved array abdominal probe. The TPUS volumes and images will be obtained with an empty bladder at rest and under full Valsalva.

Primary outcomes: Any association between sling position and subjective and objective cure rate and complication rates.

Secondary outcomes: Any association between sling position, tension or anchoring and long-term complications, especially chronic pelvic pain.

Statistics, power and sample size:

Part 2 This is a follow-up study of all women having been operated at AHUS with Ajust or TVT-A in the study period. Power calculations are not feasible as all women having had SIMS Ajust or TVT-A in the study period consenting to study participation will be analysed for subjective outcomes, whereas all women in the TVT-A group consenting to study participation will be analysed for objective outcomes.

Part 3 For the transperineal ultrasound (TPUS) we have estimated that a sample size of 107 is sufficient to draw valid conclusions. For further details on the calculation, please see the full Protocol.

Risk evaluation and countermeasures. The main risk to the project is patient inclusion. To get robust and valid scientific data we are depending on women being willing to participate in the project with clinical examinations and ultrasound measurements. We have estimated that a studyparticipation of 50% is sufficient to draw valid conclusion. For further information on this estimation please see the protocol

User Participation. The project has two user representatives. They have both participated in the planning of the project and given valuable comments in developing the study protocol. Both have agreed to stay on as part of the project group.

Ethical considerations: The Department Head at AHUS, the NFIR Management team, the NFIRs professional council, The Data Protection Officer at AHUS as well as the Regional Committee for Medical and Health Research Ethics in the Southeast of Norway (REC South East) has approved the study. Signed consent will be obtained from all study participants.

Study participants will only be examined using established techniques for the evaluation of women after incontinence surgery, the exception being the 3D ultrasound examination. None of them involves any additional risk for the participants.

Questionnaires and consent forms will be sent electronically and stored at the Services for Sensitive Data (TSD), as well as the research server at AHUS. Study participants who report persistent or recurring incontinence as well as any long-term complications related to the slings will be offered a full new clinical evaluation.