Comparing Brief, Low-Intensity Self-Improvement Exercises in a Non-Clinical Population
Comparing Brief, Low-Intensity Self-Improvement Exercises: A Randomized Trial of 21 Techniques Delivered by Mobile App
The goal of this clinical trial is to learn whether brief self-improvement exercises, practiced daily on a smartphone for four weeks, reduce depression, anxiety, and stress in adults in the United States, and which exercises help most. Participants are adults who are interested in self-improvement and have not had severe mental health challenges in the past two months. The main questions it aims to answer are:
- Does daily practice of brief self-improvement exercises lower depression, anxiety, and stress compared with daily mood tracking alone?
- Which of 21 different exercises lower depression, anxiety, and stress compared with daily mood tracking alone?
Researchers will compare participants who practice the exercises with participants who only track their mood each day to see if the exercises reduce depression, anxiety, and stress. Researchers will also compare the exercises with each other, including a few minutes of quiet rest, to learn which ones help most, which ones improve mood right away, and which ones people keep doing.
Participants will:
- Complete an online survey at the start of the study and again after four weeks
- Use the free Thought Saver smartphone app every day for 28 days
- Answer 4 short questions about their mood, energy, and productivity each day (about 1 minute)
- If assigned to the exercise group, also do 3 short exercises each day (about 2 to 3 minutes each), drawn from a personal set of 5 exercises such as gratitude writing, breathing exercises, meditation, or planning a small step toward a goal
Study Overview
Status
Status
Conditions
Conditions
Intervention / Treatment
Intervention / Treatment
- Behavioral: Wakeful Rest (active control)
- Behavioral: Thought Defusion
- Behavioral: Breath Focused Meditation
- Behavioral: Gratitude Reflection
- Behavioral: Reflective Writing About a Happy Experience
- Behavioral: Reconsider Negative Beliefs
- Behavioral: One Thing That Matters
- Behavioral: Connect with Someone You Care About
- Behavioral: Practice Goodwill
- Behavioral: Daily Intention
- Behavioral: Reflective Question
- Behavioral: Something to Look Forward To
- Behavioral: Affirmations
- Behavioral: Problem Solving
- Behavioral: Mindfulness of Emotions
- Behavioral: Three Good Things
- Behavioral: Progressive Muscle Relaxation
- Behavioral: Goal-Setting
- Behavioral: Mindfulness Meditation
- Behavioral: Paced Breathing
- Behavioral: EFT Tapping
Detailed Description
Background Brief self-improvement exercises such as gratitude journaling, breathing practices, and cognitive defusion are widely recommended in apps, books, and media. Most have been tested one at a time, against varied comparison conditions, on different outcomes, and usually as single sessions. Little is known about which of them help when practiced daily over several weeks, how they compare with one another, or which ones people keep doing. This trial compares 21 such exercises in a single study with common outcomes, a common delivery platform, and a mood-tracking control arm.
Design The study is fully remote. Screening, consent, and surveys take place online, and daily activities take place in the Thought Saver app on the participant's own smartphone. There are no study visits and no contact with study staff unless the participant initiates it. Participants are recruited online, either as unpaid volunteers (for example, through the Clearer Thinking newsletter) or as paid participants (for example, through the Positly research platform).
Randomization occurs at three levels: arm (about 80% intervention, 20% control); technique set (each intervention participant is assigned a random 5 of the 21 techniques, fixed for the study); and daily draw (each day the participant opens the app, it selects 3 of their 5 techniques at random). Both arms complete the same daily 4-item check-in and receive the same reminders. The intervention arm also completes the day's three techniques, followed by a 2-item rating of happiness and anxiety. One technique, wakeful rest (sitting quietly with no screens for 2.5 minutes), serves as an active comparison, separating the effect of a technique's content from the general effect of pausing with the app for a few minutes.
Participants are not told which condition is considered the control. Outcomes are self-reported online, and study staff are not blinded to assignment.
Analysis All randomized participants are analyzed in the group to which they were assigned. Final-survey scores are compared between arms, and between each technique and the control arm, adjusting for intake scores and recruitment source (paid vs. volunteer), with multiple imputation for missing final surveys. The daily data support within-person estimates of each technique's immediate effect on mood and of its effects on finishing the day's routine and on returning to the app the next day, as well as an analysis of what predicts dropout. Results are reported as estimates with 95% confidence intervals; false-discovery-rate adjustment across techniques is reported as an auxiliary analysis. The full analysis plan is preregistered on the Open Science Framework before enrollment begins.
Sponsor and conflicts of interest The study is sponsored by Spark Wave, LLC, which operates the study platforms (GuidedTrack and Thought Saver) and the Clearer Thinking newsletter, and is funded by a private philanthropic gift. Confirmatory analyses are conducted by an independent academic collaborator who has no financial interest in Spark Wave, and preregistered results will be published regardless of direction.
Study Type
Study Type
Enrollment (Estimated)
Enrollment
Phase
Phase
- Not Applicable
Participation Criteria
Eligibility Criteria
Eligibility Criteria
Ages Eligible for Study
Accepts Healthy Volunteers
Genders Eligible for Study
Description
Inclusion Criteria:
- Age 18 or older.
- Uses an iPhone (iOS) or Android smartphone daily.
- Interested in trying self-improvement techniques.
- Willing to commit to the study requirements (daily activities on at least 5 of every 7 days, plus intake and final surveys).
Exclusion Criteria:
- Answers "Yes" to: "Have you experienced severe mental health challenges within the last two months, such as ongoing thoughts of self-harm, suicidal ideation, bipolar disorder, or schizophrenia?"
Study Plan
How is the study designed?
Design Details
- Primary Purpose: Other
- Allocation: Randomized
- Interventional Model: Parallel Assignment
- Masking: None (Open Label)
Number of Arms
Arms and Interventions
Participant Group / ArmParticipant Group / Arm |
Intervention / TreatmentIntervention / Treatment |
|---|---|
|
Experimental: Self-improvement techniques
Participants in this arm will be randomly assigned 5 out of 21 possible self-improvement techniques, which will be administered in a mobile phone app. Each day for 28 days, they will be presented with 3 out of their assigned 5 techniques to complete that day. They will complete daily mood and productivity measures before and after using the 3 techniques. |
The participant sits quietly for 2.5 minutes with no phone, music, or other screens, timed by an in-app countdown that ends with a bell. This is the active comparison technique: it involves pausing with the app for a few minutes but has no instructional content. The participant writes down a current negative, anxious, or unhelpful thought and rates how upsetting it is (1-10). They then practice one of three defusion exercises with it (imagining it floating away on a leaf, restating it as "I'm having the thought that…", or saying it in a silly voice) and re-rate it.
Other Names:
A 2.5-minute timed meditation. The participant rests attention on the sensations of breathing without changing the breath, and gently returns to it whenever the mind wanders.
Other Names:
The participant writes three things they are grateful for, with randomly selected examples shown for inspiration. They then pick one and write about what they appreciate about it.
Other Names:
The participant recalls a time they felt happy, summarizes it in one sentence, then writes freely and in personal detail about the memory for about a minute.
Other Names:
A brief written cognitive restructuring exercise. The participant writes a negative belief about themselves, a situation, or the future; lists evidence for and against it; identifies any of nine listed thinking traps (e.g., catastrophizing, black-and-white thinking); considers what they would say to a friend who held the belief; and writes a more balanced alternative.
Other Names:
The participant names the single most important task they want to accomplish that day, the smallest first step toward it, and a specific time to take that step.
Other Names:
The participant chooses someone to contact, with randomly selected suggestions such as an old friend or a relative. During a 90-second timed prompt they decide how to reach out, then send a brief message, call, voice note, or other contact of their choosing.
Other Names:
A 2.5-minute guided loving-kindness practice. The participant directs the phrases "May you be happy. May you be safe. May you feel loved." silently or aloud, first toward someone they easily feel compassion for, then toward someone they feel neutral or negative about.
Other Names:
The participant chooses an intention for how to approach the day (e.g., being patient), turns it into one specific behavior, and writes an if-then plan naming the situation in which they will do it. The previous day's intention is pre-filled and can be kept or changed.
Other Names:
The participant reads one question drawn at random from a list of 29 (e.g., "What would you like the next chapter of your life's story to be?") and writes a free-text answer.
Other Names:
The participant spends up to 2 minutes thinking of something they are looking forward to, from later today to months away, with randomly selected examples shown. They write it down, then vividly imagine and savor it.
Other Names:
The participant chooses or writes two "honest affirmations": true, personally meaningful statements they sometimes forget (e.g., "Mistakes are part of learning and growing"). They repeat each one slowly five times, aloud or silently. Previous affirmations are pre-filled and can be kept or changed.
Other Names:
The participant names one current problem or challenge, a small concrete first step toward improving it, and when they will take that step. Previous answers are pre-filled, so they can keep working on the same problem or choose a new one. The participant pauses to notice their current emotions, with a randomly selected list of emotion words shown as prompts. They write which emotions they are feeling, trying to accept them without judgment, and why they think they feel this way. The participant writes three things that went well in the past 24 hours and their best explanation for why one of them went well.
Other Names:
A guided exercise of about 2.5 minutes. On-screen prompts lead the participant to tense and then release the chest, arms, shoulders, face, and legs in 7-second steps, twice per muscle group, followed by slow breathing. The participant writes (the first time) or reviews and updates (later times) their most important short-term (next week), medium-term (next three months), and long-term (next few years) goals. A guided meditation of about 2.5 minutes that moves attention in turn through the breath, surrounding sounds, bodily sensations, and what the participant can see, returning to the present whenever the mind wanders. A paced breathing exercise of about 2.5 minutes, done seated. On-screen prompts guide repeated cycles of inhaling through the nose for 4 seconds, holding for 4 seconds, and exhaling slowly through the mouth for 8 seconds. A guided exercise of about 3 minutes. The participant names what feels worst right now in a few words and rates its intensity (0-10). Over two rounds, they tap lightly on nine points on the hand, face, and upper body while repeating a set-up statement and a reminder phrase, then re-rate the intensity.
Other Names:
|
|
No Intervention: Measurement-only control
Participants in this condition will complete daily mood and productivity measures in the same mobile phone app as the participants in the intervention arm. They will not be offered any self-improvement techniques. |
What is the study measuring?
Primary Outcome Measures
Primary Outcome Measures
Outcome Measure |
Measure Description |
Time Frame |
|---|---|---|
|
Depression as assessed by Patient Health Questionnaire-8 (PHQ-8)
Time Frame: From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
8 items, rated on a 0-3 scale, possible range 0 to 24, with higher scores indicating greater depression. This scale is identical to the more commonly used PHQ-9, but with its final item, which assesses suicidal ideation, removed. |
From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
|
Anxiety as assessed by Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7 (GAD-7) questionnaire
Time Frame: From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
7 items rated on a 0-3 scale, possible score range 0 to 21, with higher scores indicating greater anxiety. |
From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
|
Stress as assessed by Perceived Stress Scale 10-item version (PSS-10)
Time Frame: From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
10 items rated on a 0-4 scale, possible score range 0 to 40, with higher scores indicating more psychological stress. |
From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
Secondary Outcome Measures
Secondary Outcome Measures
Outcome Measure |
Measure Description |
Time Frame |
|---|---|---|
|
Happiness as assessed by bespoke Five Factors of Happiness scale
Time Frame: From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
Scale based on Seligman's PERMA model. 23 items rated on a 1-7 Likert scale, possible score range 23-161, with higher scores indicating greater happiness. |
From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
|
Productivity as assessed by the Individual Work Performance Questionnaire (IWPQ) Task Performance scale
Time Frame: From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
5 items rated on a 0-4 Likert scale, possible score range 0 to 4, with higher scores indicating higher work performance. |
From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
|
Productivity, energy, happiness, and anxiety as assessed daily by single items
Time Frame: Daily for 28 days
|
Four items, each rated on a 1-7 Likert scale and analyzed separately:
|
Daily for 28 days
|
|
Post-technique happiness and anxiety as assessed daily by single items
Time Frame: Daily for 28 days
|
For the intervention group only, two items, each rated on a 1-7 Likert scale and analyzed separately:
|
Daily for 28 days
|
Other Outcome Measures
Other Outcome Measures
Outcome Measure |
Measure Description |
Time Frame |
|---|---|---|
|
Productivity, well-being, and functioning as assessed by additional bespoke items
Time Frame: From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
Exploratory. Six productivity items (e.g., "To what extent did you procrastinate on important tasks over the past 14 days?") and eight functioning and well-being items (e.g., "Overall, how healthy do you consider your daily habits and routines to be?"). All are rated on a 7-point Likert scale except for the item, "Over the past 14 days, what percentage of days did you feel good (rather than bad)?", which is rated in integer increments from 0% to 100%. |
From enrollment to the end of participation at day 29
|
Collaborators and Investigators
Sponsor
Sponsor
Study record dates
Study Major Dates
Study Start (Estimated)
Study Start
Primary Completion (Estimated)
Primary Completion
Study Completion (Estimated)
Study Completion
Study Registration Dates
First Submitted
First Submitted
First Submitted That Met QC Criteria
First Submitted That Met QC Criteria
First Posted (Actual)
First Posted
Study Record Updates
Last Update Posted (Actual)
Last Update Posted
Last Update Submitted That Met QC Criteria
Last Update Submitted That Met QC Criteria
Last Verified
Last Verified
More Information
Terms related to this study
Additional Relevant MeSH Terms
- Neurologic Manifestations
- Nervous System Diseases
- Mental Disorders
- Neurobehavioral Manifestations
- Neurocognitive Disorders
- Pathological Conditions, Signs and Symptoms
- Signs and Symptoms
- Anxiety Disorders
- Consciousness Disorders
- Organization and Administration
- Health Services Administration
- Therapeutics
- Mind-Body Therapies
- Complementary Therapies
- Behavior Therapy
- Psychotherapy
- Behavioral Disciplines and Activities
- Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
- Hypnosis
- Mindfulness
- Organizational Objectives
- Autogenic Training
- Cognitive Restructuring
Other Study ID Numbers
Other Study ID Numbers
- 26-405-2748
Plan for Individual participant data (IPD)
Plan to Share Individual Participant Data (IPD)?
IPD Plan Description
Fully de-identified data from all quantitative measures may be shared. A decision about whether to share qualitative data (e.g., participant responses to written exercises) will be made upon examining the responses, depending upon the level of sensitivity of those data and the ease of complete de-identification.
IPD Sharing Time Frame
Beginning at the time of publication with no end date
IPD Sharing Supporting Information Type
- STUDY_PROTOCOL
- SAP
- ICF
- ANALYTIC_CODE
Drug and device information, study documents
Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated drug product
Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated device product
This information was retrieved directly from the website clinicaltrials.gov without any changes. If you have any requests to change, remove or update your study details, please contact register@clinicaltrials.gov. As soon as a change is implemented on clinicaltrials.gov, this will be updated automatically on our website as well.