Agreement of ASA Physical Status Classification Among Anesthesia Residents, a Large Language Model, and Senior Anesthesiologist Consensus (ASA-AGREE)
Comparison of ASA Physical Status Classification by Anesthesia Residents, an Artificial Intelligence Large Language Model, and a Two-Anesthesiologist Expert Consensus: A Prospective Three-Rater Validation Study
The ASA Physical Status Classification is widely used in preoperative risk assessment, but agreement between raters is limited, particularly between ASA II and III. This prospective observational study compares the ASA class assigned to the same patients by three types of raters: anesthesia residents working in the preoperative anesthesia clinic, a large language model (LLM), and a consensus of two senior anesthesiologists, which is the reference standard.
Residents complete the standard preoperative evaluation form and assign an ASA class as part of routine care. A copy of the completed form, with patient identifiers and the resident's ASA class removed, is then given independently to the LLM and to the two senior anesthesiologists. No intervention is applied to participants and routine care is not changed.
The primary aim is to measure how closely the residents and the LLM agree with the expert consensus (weighted kappa). Secondary aims are agreement among all three raters, agreement between the two senior anesthesiologists, the direction of misclassification, and how often the LLM matches the consensus when the resident does not.
Tutkimuksen yleiskatsaus
Tila
Tila
Ehdot
Ehdot
Yksityiskohtainen kuvaus
Background The ASA Physical Status Classification is the most widely used tool for describing a patient's preoperative health status. It depends on clinical judgment, and agreement between raters is limited, especially between ASA II and III. In teaching hospitals many preoperative evaluations are done by residents. Large language models can read a structured clinical record and return a classification, and their agreement with anesthesiologists needs to be examined on real preoperative clinic data.
Design and setting Prospective, single-center, observational validation study with three rater groups, conducted in the preoperative anesthesia outpatient clinic of Kayseri City Hospital. Eligible adult patients scheduled for elective surgery are enrolled consecutively after written informed consent.
Procedures The resident takes the history, examines the patient, reviews laboratory results and consultation reports, completes the standard preoperative evaluation form and assigns an ASA class, as in routine care. The completed form is copied digitally. The resident's ASA class is stored in a locked field and is not shown to any other rater until all ratings are complete.
Two further copies are prepared in which patient identifiers (name, archive number, date) and the resident's ASA class, including any ASA checkbox and the free-text assessment, are masked. One copy goes to the LLM and the other to the two senior anesthesiologists.
The LLM is Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic), used through the Claude web interface (claude.ai), as a clinician would use it in practice. A dedicated study account is used, with memory and personalization turned off and no custom instructions. Each masked form image is entered in a new chat with the same fixed prompt. The model is queried once per patient, its response is saved verbatim with a screenshot, and the ASA class is entered into the database independently by two investigators. No patient identifiers are sent to the model.
The two senior anesthesiologists (more than 10 years of experience, not involved in the patient's perioperative care) classify each masked form independently. When they disagree, they discuss the case and record a consensus class and the reason. The consensus class is the reference standard. Agreement between the two experts before consensus is reported as a separate result.
Sample size Target enrollment is 330 patients, with 300 analyzable forms expected after allowing for 10% incomplete or excluded forms. The sample size was determined by Monte Carlo simulation for the primary comparison, the difference between two dependent quadratic weighted kappas (LLM vs consensus and resident vs consensus). Assuming a resident-consensus kappa of 0.45 and a clinically relevant difference of 0.15, 300 analyzable patients give 83% power at a two-sided alpha of 0.05.
Statistical analysis Agreement of the resident and of the LLM with the expert consensus is measured with quadratic weighted Cohen's kappa. The primary comparison is the difference between the two kappas, tested with a paired bootstrap 95% confidence interval (2000 resamples of patients). Agreement among all three raters is measured with Fleiss' kappa. Misclassification is described by direction (under- or over-classification) using confusion matrices. The ASA II-III boundary, resident training year and the inter-expert subgroup are pre-specified subgroup analyses. Predictors of resident misclassification are examined with logistic regression. All tests are two-sided at alpha 0.05; secondary comparisons are reported with 95% confidence intervals and treated as exploratory.
Opintotyyppi
Opintotyyppi
Ilmoittautuminen (Arvioitu)
Ilmoittautuminen
Yhteystiedot ja paikat
Opiskeluyhteys
Opiskeluyhteys
- Nimi: Çiğdem Ünal Kantekin, MD
- Puhelinnumero: +90 352 315 77 00
- Sähköposti: drcgdm@gmail.com
Opiskelupaikat
-
-
-
Kayseri, Turkki (Türkiye), 38080
- Kayseri City Hospital, Department of Anesthesiology and Reanimation
-
Ottaa yhteyttä:
- Çiğdem Ünal Kantekin, MD
- Puhelinnumero: +90 352 315 77 00
- Sähköposti: drcgdm@gmail.com
-
-
Osallistumiskriteerit
Kelpoisuusvaatimukset
Kelpoisuusvaatimukset
Opintokelpoiset iät
Hyväksyy terveitä vapaaehtoisia
Sukupuolet, jotka voivat opiskella
Näytteenottomenetelmä
Tutkimusväestö
Adult patients scheduled for elective surgery who attend the preoperative anesthesia outpatient clinic of Kayseri City Hospital and whose standard preoperative evaluation form is completed by a resident.
Kuvaus
Inclusion Criteria:
- Age 18 years or older
- Scheduled for elective surgery and evaluated at the preoperative anesthesia clinic
- Standard preoperative evaluation form completed by a resident, with required laboratory results and consultation reports entered
- Written informed consent
Exclusion Criteria:
- Emergency or semi-urgent surgery
- Incomplete preoperative evaluation form
- Unable to give informed consent (for example, because of a psychiatric disorder)
- Refusal to participate
Opintosuunnitelma
Miten tutkimus on suunniteltu?
Suunnittelun yksityiskohdat
- Havaintomallit: COHORT
- Aikanäkymät: PROSPECTIVE
Ryhmien/kohorttien lukumäärä
Kohortit ja interventiot
Ryhmä/KohorttiRyhmä/Kohortti |
|---|
|
Preoperative anesthesia clinic patients
Adult patients scheduled for elective surgery who are evaluated at the preoperative anesthesia outpatient clinic. The anonymized preoperative form of each patient is rated for ASA class by a resident, an LLM and two senior anesthesiologists. |
Mitä tutkimuksessa mitataan?
Ensisijaiset tulostoimenpiteet
Ensisijaiset tulostoimenpiteet
Tulosmittaus |
Toimenpiteen kuvaus |
Aikaikkuna |
|---|---|---|
|
Agreement between resident and expert-consensus ASA classification (quadratic weighted kappa)
Aikaikkuna: Once per patient, from the preoperative clinic evaluation until completion of the blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks)
|
Quadratic weighted Cohen's kappa between the ASA physical status class (I to V) assigned by the anesthesia resident and the consensus class assigned by two senior anesthesiologists who were blinded to the resident's class. The consensus class is the reference standard. A value of 1 indicates perfect agreement, 0 indicates chance agreement, and negative values indicate agreement below chance. |
Once per patient, from the preoperative clinic evaluation until completion of the blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks)
|
|
Agreement between large language model and expert-consensus ASA classification (quadratic weighted kappa)
Aikaikkuna: Once per patient, from the preoperative clinic evaluation until completion of the blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks)
|
Quadratic weighted Cohen's kappa between the ASA class assigned by the large language model from the anonymized preoperative form and the consensus class of two senior anesthesiologists. The model does not see the resident's class or any patient identifier. |
Once per patient, from the preoperative clinic evaluation until completion of the blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks)
|
Toissijaiset tulostoimenpiteet
Toissijaiset tulostoimenpiteet
Tulosmittaus |
Toimenpiteen kuvaus |
Aikaikkuna |
|---|---|---|
|
Three-rater agreement of ASA classification (Fleiss' kappa)
Aikaikkuna: From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
Fleiss' kappa across the resident class, the large language model class and the expert consensus class for each patient. |
From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
|
Agreement between the two senior anesthesiologists before consensus (quadratic weighted kappa)
Aikaikkuna: From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
Quadratic weighted kappa between the independent ASA classes of senior anesthesiologist A and B, calculated before any discussion between them. |
From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
|
Agreement between resident and large language model ASA classification (quadratic weighted kappa)
Aikaikkuna: From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
Quadratic weighted kappa between the ASA class assigned by the resident and the class assigned by the large language model. |
From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
|
Direction of misclassification relative to expert consensus
Aikaikkuna: From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
Proportion of patients classified lower (under-classification) or higher (over-classification) than the expert consensus, reported separately for residents and for the large language model. The ASA II-III boundary is analyzed as a pre-specified subgroup. |
From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
|
Proportion of resident misclassifications in which the large language model matches expert consensus
Aikaikkuna: From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
Among patients whose resident ASA class differs from the expert consensus, the proportion for whom the large language model class equals the consensus class. This is an exploratory measure of decision-support potential. |
From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
|
Factors associated with resident misclassification
Aikaikkuna: From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
Odds ratios from logistic regression of resident misclassification (yes or no) on age, body mass index, number of ASA-relevant comorbidities, resident training year and borderline ASA II-III status. |
From the preoperative evaluation to completion of blinded ratings (up to 4 weeks per patient); assessed at the end of data collection (up to 8 months).
|
Yhteistyökumppanit ja tutkijat
Sponsori
Sponsori
Tutkijat
Tutkijat
- Päätutkija: Çiğdem Ünal Kantekin, MD, Kayseri City Hospital
Opintojen ennätyspäivät
Opi tärkeimmät päivämäärät
Opiskelun aloitus (Arvioitu)
Opiskelun aloitus
Ensisijainen valmistuminen (Arvioitu)
Ensisijainen valmistuminen
Opintojen valmistuminen (Arvioitu)
Opintojen valmistuminen
Opintoihin ilmoittautumispäivät
Ensimmäinen lähetetty
Ensimmäinen lähetetty
Ensimmäinen toimitettu, joka täytti QC-kriteerit
Ensimmäinen toimitettu, joka täytti QC-kriteerit
Ensimmäinen Lähetetty (Todellinen)
Ensimmäinen Lähetetty
Tutkimustietojen päivitykset
Viimeisin päivitys julkaistu (Todellinen)
Viimeisin päivitys julkaistu
Viimeisin lähetetty päivitys, joka täytti QC-kriteerit
Viimeisin lähetetty päivitys, joka täytti QC-kriteerit
Viimeksi vahvistettu
Viimeksi vahvistettu
Lisää tietoa
Tähän tutkimukseen liittyvät termit
Avainsanat
Muut tutkimustunnusnumerot
Muut tutkimustunnusnumerot
- ASA-AGREE-2026-01
- 1208 (Muu tunniste: Kayseri City Hospital Non-Interventional Clinical Research Ethics Committee)
Yksittäisten osallistujien tietojen suunnitelma (IPD)
Aiotko jakaa yksittäisten osallistujien tietoja (IPD)?
IPD-suunnitelman kuvaus
Individual participant data will not be shared outside the study team. The consent form covers coded, confidential use of the data for this study only. Aggregate results will be published.
Lääke- ja laitetiedot, tutkimusasiakirjat
Tutkii yhdysvaltalaista FDA sääntelemää lääkevalmistetta
Tutkii yhdysvaltalaista FDA sääntelemää laitetuotetta
Nämä tiedot haettiin suoraan verkkosivustolta clinicaltrials.gov ilman muutoksia. Jos sinulla on pyyntöjä muuttaa, poistaa tai päivittää tutkimustietojasi, ota yhteyttä register@clinicaltrials.gov. Heti kun muutos on otettu käyttöön osoitteessa clinicaltrials.gov, se päivitetään automaattisesti myös verkkosivustollemme .