Microbial Contamination of Different Toothbrush Types Stored in Bathrooms and Rooms in Adolescents
Microbial Contamination of Silver Nanoparticle, Bamboo Charcoal and Standard Toothbrushes Stored in Bathroom Versus Room Environments: A Randomized Clinical Study in Adolescents
This randomized clinical study aimed to compare microbial contamination of three different toothbrush types (standard plastic, silver nanoparticle, and bamboo charcoal) and to investigate whether storing toothbrushes in a bathroom or a room outside the bathroom affects microbial contamination.
The study included 72 healthy adolescents aged 11-18 years who were undergoing removable orthodontic appliance treatment. Participants were randomly assigned to one of three toothbrush groups and two storage conditions (bathroom or room). All participants received standardized oral hygiene instructions and used their assigned toothbrushes twice daily for one month.
After one month, the toothbrushes were collected and examined for the presence of three microorganisms: *Streptococcus mutans*, *Lactobacillus* spp., and *Candida albicans*. In addition, plaque index, gingival index, probing depth, and bleeding on probing were assessed at baseline and after one month.
The study was designed to determine whether toothbrushes marketed as having antimicrobial properties and different storage environments influence microbial contamination and short-term periodontal health.
Studie Overzicht
Toestand
Toestand
Conditie
Conditie
Interventie / Behandeling
Interventie / Behandeling
Gedetailleerde beschrijving
This randomized, parallel-group clinical study was conducted at Afyonkarahisar Health Sciences University, Türkiye, between March 2021 and July 2022. The study investigated the effects of toothbrush type and storage environment on microbial contamination under routine home-use conditions.
Participants were randomly allocated to three toothbrush groups: standard plastic (Colgate Extra Clean), silver nanoparticle (Splat Sensitive Silver), and bamboo charcoal (Colgate Bamboo Charcoal). Each group was further divided into two storage subgroups: bathroom storage and room storage outside the bathroom. Randomization was performed using colored balls drawn by an investigator who was not involved in clinical or microbiological assessments. The microbiologist was blinded to group allocation.
At baseline, all participants received professional prophylaxis and standardized oral hygiene instructions. Participants were instructed to brush twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman technique and the same fluoride toothpaste. After brushing, toothbrushes were rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the assigned environment. Toothbrushes were not shared or stored in contact with other toothbrushes.
After one month, the used toothbrushes were collected in sterile bags. Under aseptic conditions, one-third of the bristles were removed and transferred into thioglycolate broth. Samples were transported under refrigerated conditions to the microbiology laboratory. Following broth enrichment, samples were cultured on selective media to detect *Streptococcus mutans*, *Lactobacillus* spp., and *Candida albicans*. Suspected isolates were identified using the VITEK 2 Compact system.
Microbial contamination was evaluated based on the presence or absence of each target microorganism rather than quantitative bacterial counts.
Clinical periodontal assessments were performed at baseline and after one month using standardized measurements of plaque index, gingival index, probing depth, and bleeding on probing.
The study was approved by the Clinical Research Ethics Committee of Afyonkarahisar Health Sciences University (approval number: 2020/13; November 6, 2020). Written informed consent was obtained from parents or legal guardians, and assent was obtained from participants.
Studietype
Studietype
Inschrijving (Werkelijk)
Inschrijving
Fase
Fase
- Niet toepasbaar
Contacten en locaties
Studie Locaties
-
-
-
Afyonkarahisar, Turkije (Türkiye)
- Afyonkarahisar Health Sciences University
-
-
Deelname Criteria
Geschiktheidscriteria
Geschiktheidscriteria
Leeftijden die in aanmerking komen voor studie
Accepteert gezonde vrijwilligers
Geslachten die in aanmerking komen voor studie
Beschrijving
Inclusion Criteria:
- Adolescents aged 11-18 years.
- Systemically healthy individuals.
- Patients undergoing dentofacial orthopedic treatment with removable functional appliances.
Exclusion Criteria:
- Use of systemic antibiotics within the previous 3 months.
- Use of antimicrobial mouthwash within the previous 3 months.
- Presence of systemic disease.
- Smoking.
Studie plan
Hoe is de studie opgezet?
Ontwerpdetails
- Primair doel: Preventie
- Toewijzing: Gerandomiseerd
- Interventioneel model: Faculteitstoewijzing
- Masker: Enkel
Aantal wapens
Wapens en interventies
Deelnemersgroep / ArmDeelnemersgroep / Arm |
Interventie / BehandelingInterventie / Behandeling |
|---|---|
|
Actieve vergelijker: Standard Toothbrush - Bathroom
Participants assigned to this arm used a standard plastic toothbrush (Colgate Extra Clean) twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman brushing technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the bathroom. The intervention lasted one month, after which the toothbrush was collected for microbiological analysis. |
A commercially available standard plastic toothbrush (Colgate Extra Clean, Colgate-Palmolive Company, New York, NY, USA) was used as the active comparator. Participants brushed their teeth twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste for one month. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the assigned storage environment (bathroom or room outside the bathroom). At the end of the intervention period, toothbrushes were collected for microbiological analysis. |
|
Actieve vergelijker: Standard Toothbrush - Room
Participants assigned to this arm used a standard plastic toothbrush (Colgate Extra Clean) twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman brushing technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in a room outside the bathroom. The intervention lasted one month, after which the toothbrush was collected for microbiological analysis. |
A commercially available standard plastic toothbrush (Colgate Extra Clean, Colgate-Palmolive Company, New York, NY, USA) was used as the active comparator. Participants brushed their teeth twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste for one month. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the assigned storage environment (bathroom or room outside the bathroom). At the end of the intervention period, toothbrushes were collected for microbiological analysis. |
|
Experimenteel: Silver Nanoparticle Toothbrush - Bathroom
Participants assigned to this arm used a silver nanoparticle-containing toothbrush (Splat Sensitive Silver) twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman brushing technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the bathroom. The intervention lasted one month, after which the toothbrush was collected for microbiological analysis. |
A commercially available silver nanoparticle-containing toothbrush (Splat Sensitive Silver, SPLAT-COSMETICA, Moscow, Russia) was used to evaluate microbial contamination compared with a standard plastic toothbrush. Participants brushed their teeth twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste for one month. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the assigned storage environment (bathroom or room outside the bathroom). At the end of the intervention period, toothbrushes were collected for microbiological analysis. |
|
Experimenteel: Silver Nanoparticle Toothbrush - Room
Participants assigned to this arm used a silver nanoparticle-containing toothbrush (Splat Sensitive Silver) twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman brushing technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in a room outside the bathroom. The intervention lasted one month, after which the toothbrush was collected for microbiological analysis. |
A commercially available silver nanoparticle-containing toothbrush (Splat Sensitive Silver, SPLAT-COSMETICA, Moscow, Russia) was used to evaluate microbial contamination compared with a standard plastic toothbrush. Participants brushed their teeth twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste for one month. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the assigned storage environment (bathroom or room outside the bathroom). At the end of the intervention period, toothbrushes were collected for microbiological analysis. |
|
Experimenteel: Bamboo Charcoal Toothbrush - Bathroom
Participants assigned to this arm used a bamboo charcoal toothbrush (Colgate Bamboo Charcoal) twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman brushing technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the bathroom. The intervention lasted one month, after which the toothbrush was collected for microbiological analysis. |
A commercially available bamboo charcoal toothbrush (Colgate Bamboo Charcoal, Colgate-Palmolive Company, New York, NY, USA) was used to evaluate microbial contamination compared with a standard plastic toothbrush. Participants brushed their teeth twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste for one month. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the assigned storage environment (bathroom or room outside the bathroom). At the end of the intervention period, toothbrushes were collected for microbiological analysis. |
|
Experimenteel: Bamboo Charcoal Toothbrush - Room
Participants assigned to this arm used a bamboo charcoal toothbrush (Colgate Bamboo Charcoal) twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman brushing technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in a room outside the bathroom. The intervention lasted one month, after which the toothbrush was collected for microbiological analysis. |
A commercially available bamboo charcoal toothbrush (Colgate Bamboo Charcoal, Colgate-Palmolive Company, New York, NY, USA) was used to evaluate microbial contamination compared with a standard plastic toothbrush. Participants brushed their teeth twice daily for two minutes using the modified Stillman technique and standardized fluoride toothpaste for one month. After each use, the toothbrush was rinsed under tap water and stored upright and uncovered in the assigned storage environment (bathroom or room outside the bathroom). At the end of the intervention period, toothbrushes were collected for microbiological analysis. |
Wat meet het onderzoek?
Primaire uitkomstmaten
Primaire uitkomstmaten
Uitkomstmaat |
Maatregel Beschrijving |
Tijdsspanne |
|---|---|---|
|
Presence of Streptococcus mutans on Toothbrushes
Tijdsspanne: 1 month after baseline (end of toothbrush use)
|
The presence or absence of Streptococcus mutans on toothbrush bristles was assessed after one month of use. Bristle samples were cultured on selective Mitis Salivarius agar supplemented with bacitracin and potassium tellurite following broth enrichment. Suspected isolates were identified using the VITEK 2 Compact system. The outcome was recorded as a binary variable (detected/not detected), and the proportion of contaminated toothbrushes was compared across toothbrush types and storage environments. |
1 month after baseline (end of toothbrush use)
|
|
Presence of Lactobacillus spp. on Toothbrushes
Tijdsspanne: 1 month after baseline (end of toothbrush use)
|
The presence or absence of Lactobacillus spp. on toothbrush bristles was assessed after one month of use. Bristle samples were cultured on Rogosa agar adjusted to pH 5.5 following broth enrichment. Suspected isolates were identified using the VITEK 2 Compact system. The outcome was recorded as a binary variable (detected/not detected), and the proportion of contaminated toothbrushes was compared across toothbrush types and storage environments. |
1 month after baseline (end of toothbrush use)
|
|
Presence of Candida albicans on Toothbrushes
Tijdsspanne: 1 month after baseline (end of toothbrush use)
|
The presence or absence of Candida albicans on toothbrush bristles was assessed after one month of use. Bristle samples were cultured on Sabouraud dextrose agar supplemented with chloramphenicol following broth enrichment. Suspected isolates were identified using the VITEK 2 Compact system. The outcome was recorded as a binary variable (detected/not detected), and the proportion of contaminated toothbrushes was compared across toothbrush types and storage environments. |
1 month after baseline (end of toothbrush use)
|
Secundaire uitkomstmaten
Secundaire uitkomstmaten
Uitkomstmaat |
Maatregel Beschrijving |
Tijdsspanne |
|---|---|---|
|
Change in Plaque Index From Baseline to One Month
Tijdsspanne: Baseline and 1 month
|
Dental plaque accumulation was assessed using the Silness and Löe Plaque Index at baseline and after one month of toothbrush use. The change in plaque index was calculated by subtracting the baseline score from the one-month score. Changes were compared across toothbrush types and storage environments. Lower scores indicate less plaque accumulation. |
Baseline and 1 month
|
|
Change in Gingival Index From Baseline to One Month
Tijdsspanne: Baseline and 1 month
|
Gingival inflammation was assessed using the Löe and Silness Gingival Index at baseline and after one month of toothbrush use. The change in gingival index was calculated by subtracting the baseline score from the one-month score. Changes were compared across toothbrush types and storage environments. Lower scores indicate less gingival inflammation. |
Baseline and 1 month
|
|
Change in Buccal Probing Depth From Baseline to One Month
Tijdsspanne: Baseline and 1 month
|
Buccal periodontal probing depth was measured in millimeters using a periodontal probe (Hu-Friedy No. 15) at baseline and after one month of toothbrush use. Measurements were obtained as part of a standardized six-site periodontal examination of all teeth present. The change in buccal probing depth was calculated by subtracting the baseline value from the one-month value. Changes were compared across toothbrush types and storage environments. Positive values indicate an increase in probing depth. |
Baseline and 1 month
|
|
Change in Lingual Probing Depth From Baseline to One Month
Tijdsspanne: Baseline and 1 month
|
Lingual periodontal probing depth was measured in millimeters using a periodontal probe (Hu-Friedy No. 15) at baseline and after one month of toothbrush use. Measurements were obtained as part of a standardized six-site periodontal examination of all teeth present. The change in lingual probing depth was calculated by subtracting the baseline value from the one-month value. Changes were compared across toothbrush types and storage environments. Positive values indicate an increase in probing depth. |
Baseline and 1 month
|
|
Change in Bleeding on Probing From Baseline to One Month
Tijdsspanne: Baseline and 1 month
|
Bleeding on probing (BOP) was assessed at six sites per tooth using a periodontal probe (Hu-Friedy No. 15) at baseline and after one month of toothbrush use. BOP was expressed as the percentage of examined sites exhibiting bleeding. The change in BOP was calculated by subtracting the baseline percentage from the one-month percentage and was expressed in percentage points. Changes were compared across toothbrush types and storage environments. Negative values indicate a reduction in gingival bleeding. |
Baseline and 1 month
|
Medewerkers en onderzoekers
Sponsor
Sponsor
Publicaties en nuttige links
Algemene publicaties
- Frazelle MR, Munro CL. Toothbrush contamination: a review of the literature. Nurs Res Pract. 2012;2012:420630. doi: 10.1155/2012/420630. Epub 2012 Jan 24.
- Thamke MV, Beldar A, Thakkar P, Murkute S, Ranmare V, Hudwekar A. Comparison of Bacterial Contamination and Antibacterial Efficacy in Bristles of Charcoal Toothbrushes versus Noncharcoal Toothbrushes: A Microbiological Study. Contemp Clin Dent. 2018 Jul-Sep;9(3):463-467. doi: 10.4103/ccd.ccd_309_18.
- Baygin O, Tuzuner T, Yilmaz N, Aksoy S. Short-term antibacterial efficacy of a new silver nanoparticle-containing toothbrush. J Pak Med Assoc. 2017 May;67(5):818-819. No abstract available.
Studie record data
Bestudeer belangrijke data
Studie start (Werkelijk)
Studie start
Primaire voltooiing (Werkelijk)
Primaire voltooiing
Studie voltooiing (Werkelijk)
Studie voltooiing
Studieregistratiedata
Eerst ingediend
Eerst ingediend
Eerst ingediend dat voldeed aan de QC-criteria
Eerst ingediend dat voldeed aan de QC-criteria
Eerst geplaatst (Werkelijk)
Eerst geplaatst
Updates van studierecords
Laatste update geplaatst (Werkelijk)
Laatste update geplaatst
Laatste update ingediend die voldeed aan QC-criteria
Laatste update ingediend die voldeed aan QC-criteria
Laatst geverifieerd
Laatst geverifieerd
Meer informatie
Termen gerelateerd aan deze studie
Trefwoorden
Andere studie-ID-nummers
Andere studie-ID-nummers
- Seher Gözde Uğur
- 21.DUS.001 (Ander subsidie-/financieringsnummer: Afyonkarahisar Health Sciences University - Scientific Research Projects Coordination Unit)
Plan Individuele Deelnemersgegevens (IPD)
Bent u van plan om gegevens van individuele deelnemers (IPD) te delen?
Beschrijving IPD-plan
Individual participant data (IPD) will not be made publicly available due to participant confidentiality and privacy considerations, as the study involved adolescents. The study was conducted under institutional ethical approval, and no formal IPD sharing plan was established.
Informatie over medicijnen en apparaten, studiedocumenten
Bestudeert een door de Amerikaanse FDA gereguleerd geneesmiddel
Bestudeert een door de Amerikaanse FDA gereguleerd apparaatproduct
Deze informatie is zonder wijzigingen rechtstreeks van de website clinicaltrials.gov gehaald. Als u verzoeken heeft om uw onderzoeksgegevens te wijzigen, te verwijderen of bij te werken, neem dan contact op met register@clinicaltrials.gov. Zodra er een wijziging wordt doorgevoerd op clinicaltrials.gov, wordt deze ook automatisch bijgewerkt op onze website .