Тестирование нового метода улучшения информированного согласия в исследованиях в тюрьмах (Spark BATIR)
Understanding of informed consent is often limited in prison, due to unique challenges faced by detained people. This study will test a modified "teach-to-goal" informed consent process compared to standard procedures. Conducted within a larger study on psychiatric outcomes, it aims to enhance ethical practices for vulnerable populations.
Обзор исследования
Статус
Статус
Условия
Условия
Вмешательство/лечение
Вмешательство/лечение
Подробное описание
Background and rationale. Informed consent is an ethical pillar of health-related research involving human subjects, but participants' understanding of informed consent is often limited. Informed consent is also a critical issue in prison research.
First, detained persons are deprived from liberty, a context that may undermine voluntary participation and autonomy. Second, detained persons have disproportionally low levels of education, literacy, and high rates of cognitive or substance- and psychiatric-related impairments. In Switzerland, a study conducted in the general population concluded that informed consent forms are too long and complex. Another study conducted in prison showed a full understanding of 5% in detained persons. Of note, a revision of the Federal Human Research Act (HRA) has just begun and includes propositions to strengthen informed consent. Nonetheless, few studies focused on understanding of informed consent in prison research and to our knowledge, no study with a robust methodology tested whether the most effective interventions in the general population are also effective in prison. Objective of the study. The overarching aim of this study is to estimate and improve understanding of informed consent in prison research, and better understanding characteristics associated with a low understanding. The informed consent process is a time-consuming process and studies may lack resources to ensure that participants provide fully informed consent. To fill in this critical research gap, this study will be embedded in a larger randomized controlled trial (RCT) ("parent-RCT") designed to improve psychiatric outcomes. We will use an RCT to compare two informed consent processes. Methods. This is a cross-sectional RCT (ratio 1:1) testing the effect of informed consent processes on understanding (primary endpoint) and evaluation (secondary endpoints) of informed consent. The research team and will not be blinded to the participants' group, but the statistician will be. Participants will be partially blinded. Data will be collected in four prisons among sentenced persons (n=100). The intervention will be modified "teach-to-goal" vs. standard informed consent process. In the modified teach-to-goal intervention, the participant is asked to describe the research procedures. Misconceptions are corrected by a study team member and the participant is asked to describe again the corresponding components. The procedure is iterated until correct and full understanding is reached. Analyses will include intention-to-treat bivariable and multivariable regressions. We will also explore associations between understanding and socio-demographic variables using logistic, linear or negative-binomial regressions, to identify characteristics associated with lower understanding. Expected results and impact. There is a growing recognition that prison research is needed. Improving informed consent in prison research therefore constitutes a critical but neglected issue, both as a separate research topic and for future research projects focusing on detained persons and more broadly, on vulnerable populations. Embedding a RCT on informed consent in an already existing RCT is an unconventional research process. We believe that it will provide "real (study) life" information on how informed consent is informed and ways to improve it. It will also ensure that ethical requirements are fully met in the parent-RCT. This study will thus provide scientific evidence on how to improve informed consent in prison research.
Results will be valuable for other vulnerable populations, including people with low levels of education and literacy and high burden of disease. We plan to publish results in a high-impact biomedical journal and to share them in international conferences and with Swiss cantonal Ethics Committees to raise awareness on informed consent as a core component of medical ethics in research, and more specifically, research involving vulnerable populations. The project may provide meaningful information for the revision of the HRA and help improving informed consent processes in Swiss research.
Тип исследования
Тип исследования
Регистрация (Действительный)
Регистрация
Фаза
Фаза
- Непригодный
Контакты и местонахождение
Места учебы
-
-
Canton of Geneva
-
Geneva, Canton of Geneva, Швейцария, 1211
- Geneva University Hospitals
-
Geneva, Canton of Geneva, Швейцария, 1226
- Geneva University Hospitals
-
-
Критерии участия
Критерии приемлемости
Критерии приемлемости
Возраст, подходящий для обучения
Принимает здоровых добровольцев
Полы, имеющие право на обучение
Описание
Inclusion Criteria:
- screened in the parent-RCT
- age ≥ 18 years
- good command of French
- absence of acute psychiatric disorder
- providing written informed consent for study participation in the parent-RCT
Exclusion Criteria:
- none.
Учебный план
Как устроено исследование?
Детали дизайна
- Основная цель: Фундаментальная наука
- Распределение: Рандомизированный
- Интервенционная модель: Параллельное назначение
- Маскировка: Одинокий
Количество рук
Оружие и интервенции
Группа участников / АрмияГруппа участников / Армия |
Вмешательство/лечениеВмешательство/лечение |
|---|---|
|
Без вмешательства: Standard informed consent
According to ethical requirements of Swiss Human Research Act, the interviewer will explain the nature of the study, its purposes, duration, the potential risks and benefits it entails, and study procedures. He will inform that study participation is voluntary and that participants may withdraw at any time. He will also explain that the study is independent from the prison authorities. Participants will then be given time to read the informed consent, or, if they are not able to read, it will be read to them by the interviewer. The interviewer will answer all questions. |
|
|
Экспериментальный: Modified teach-to-goal informed consent
The standard process will first be used. After that, the interviewer will ask participants to summarize the content of the informed consent. The interviewer will correct not-well understood components and ask questions about forgotten components. In case of misconceptions, the participant will be asked to summarize again the corresponding components. A list of key components to be addressed will be developed by study team members, including experts in prison research and ethics, based on components listed in Art. 16 of the Swiss Human Research Act. The material of the informed consent of the parent-randomized controlled trial will be used. |
Enhanced procedure to improve informed consent in vulnerable populations. |
Что измеряет исследование?
Первичные показатели результатов
Первичные показатели результатов
Мера результата |
Мера Описание |
Временное ограничение |
|---|---|---|
|
Understanding of the informed consent (binary)
Временное ограничение: Immediately after the intervention
|
20 questions (true/false) evaluating whether the participant understood the information. A binary variable coded 1 if all questions are answered correctly and 0 otherwise will be computed. |
Immediately after the intervention
|
Вторичные показатели результатов
Вторичные показатели результатов
Мера результата |
Мера Описание |
Временное ограничение |
|---|---|---|
|
Understanding of the informed consent (continuous)
Временное ограничение: Immediately after the intervention
|
20 questions (true/false) evaluating whether the participant understood the information. A score between 0 and 20 will be developed. |
Immediately after the intervention
|
|
Evaluation of the informed consent
Временное ограничение: Immediately after the intervention
|
10 questions evaluated on a Likert 6-point scale evaluating what the participants thought of the information. A score between 0 and 50 will be computed. |
Immediately after the intervention
|
Соавторы и исследователи
Спонсор
Спонсор
Соавторы
Соавторы
Даты записи исследования
Изучение основных дат
Начало исследования (Действительный)
Начало исследования
Первичное завершение (Действительный)
Первичное завершение
Завершение исследования (Действительный)
Завершение исследования
Даты регистрации исследования
Первый отправленный
Первый отправленный
Впервые представлено, что соответствует критериям контроля качества
Впервые представлено, что соответствует критериям контроля качества
Первый опубликованный (Действительный)
Первый опубликованный
Обновления учебных записей
Последнее опубликованное обновление (Действительный)
Последнее опубликованное обновление
Последнее отправленное обновление, отвечающее критериям контроля качества
Последнее отправленное обновление, отвечающее критериям контроля качества
Последняя проверка
Последняя проверка
Дополнительная информация
Термины, связанные с этим исследованием
Ключевые слова
Дополнительные соответствующие термины MeSH
Другие идентификационные номера исследования
Другие идентификационные номера исследования
- CRSK-3_221381
Планирование данных отдельных участников (IPD)
Планируете делиться данными об отдельных участниках (IPD)?
Информация о лекарствах и устройствах, исследовательские документы
Изучает лекарственный продукт, регулируемый FDA США.
Изучает продукт устройства, регулируемый Управлением по санитарному надзору за качеством пищевых продуктов и медикаментов США.
Эта информация была получена непосредственно с веб-сайта clinicaltrials.gov без каких-либо изменений. Если у вас есть запросы на изменение, удаление или обновление сведений об исследовании, обращайтесь по адресу register@clinicaltrials.gov. Как только изменение будет реализовано на clinicaltrials.gov, оно будет автоматически обновлено и на нашем веб-сайте. .