Endoscopic (EID) Versus Surgical (TAMIS) Local Excision for Early Stage Rectal Cancer (ENSURE)
Endoscopic Intermuscular Dissection Versus Transanal Minimally Invasive Surgery for Local Excision of Early Rectal Cancer: a Multicenter Randomized Controlled Trial
In this clinical trial, we compare the endoscopic technique, endoscopic intermuscular dissection (EID), with the surgical technique, transanal minimally invasive surgery (TAMIS) for the treatment of early stage rectal cancer. The aim of this study is to investigate whether one of them leads to better outcomes.
Researchers will focus particularly on:
- How effectively each technique completely removes the cancer
- How quickly patients recover after treatment and whether complications occur
- Outcomes after three years (does the cancer go away, or does it come back?)
- The impact of both techniques on bowel function and quality of life
Participants will:
- Be randomly assigned to receive either surgical or endoscopic treatment for their rectal cancer
- Keep a diary twice a day to record pain symptoms and recovery during the first 30 days after treatment and complete questionnaires within a 3 year period
- Visit the clinic for follow-up appointments within a 3 year period
Panoramica dello studio
Stato
Stato
Condizioni
Condizioni
Intervento / Trattamento
Intervento / Trattamento
Descrizione dettagliata
In the Netherlands, more than 3,000 people are diagnosed with rectal cancer each year. Approximately one-third of these patients have early-stage disease (cT1-2N0M0). Due to the low risk of lymph node metastasis, these cancers are potentially suitable for local, organ-preserving treatment. If histological analysis confirms complete removal without high-risk features, major rectal surgery can be avoided. For suspected deep submucosal invasive cancer of the rectum, a local excision (LE) can be performed by gastroenterologists using EID or by surgeons using TAMIS. Although both LE approaches are considered standard treatment for early stage rectal cancer (T1b), they have never been directly compared. This national study aims to compare the efficacy, safety, and cost-effectiveness of these two approaches. Should both techniques prove equally effective at completely removing rectal T1b, EID may offer a less burdensome and more cost-effective treatment option.
Tipo di studio
Tipo di studio
Iscrizione (Stimato)
Iscrizione
Fase
Fase
- Non applicabile
Contatti e Sedi
Contatto studio
Contatto studio
- Nome: Elena A Kasantsidis, MD
- Numero di telefono: +31 651768033
- Email: e.a.kasantsidis@amsterdamumc.nl
Luoghi di studio
-
-
-
Alkmaar, Olanda
- NoordWest Ziekenhuisgroep
-
Contatto:
- Wing Liu
- Numero di telefono: +31 72 - 548 3324
- Email: w.s.liu@nwz.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Mich Dunker, MD PhD
-
Almere Stad, Olanda
- Flevoziekenhuis
-
Contatto:
- Krista Lam
- Numero di telefono: +31 36 868 86 16
- Email: krlam@flevoziekenhuis.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Anthony van de Ven, MD
-
Amersfoort, Olanda, 3813 TZ
- Meander Medisch Centrum
-
Contatto:
- Nienke Hennequin
- Numero di telefono: +31 33 8505050
- Email: nl.hennequin@meandermc.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Esther Consten, MD PhD
-
Amsterdam, Olanda
- OLVG
-
Contatto:
- Simone Röttgering
- Numero di telefono: +31 20 510 87 77
- Email: s.rottgering@olvg.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Michael Gerhards, MD PhD
-
Amsterdam, Olanda, 1081 HV
- Amsterdam UMC
-
Contatto:
- Elena A Kasantsidis, MD
- Numero di telefono: +31 651768033
- Email: ENSURE@amsterdamumc.nl
-
Sub-investigatore:
- Elena Kasantsidis, MD
-
Investigatore principale:
- Barbara Bastiaansen, MD
-
Amsterdam, Olanda
- Antoni Van Leeuwenhoek
-
Contatto:
- Yanaika Tankink
- Numero di telefono: +31 020 512 9111
- Email: y.tankink@nki.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Brechtje Grotenhuis, MD PhD
-
Capelle aan den IJssel, Olanda
- Ijsselland Ziekenhuis
-
Contatto:
- Sita Willigen
- Numero di telefono: +31 102585180
- Email: swilligen@ysl.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Pascal Doornebosch, MD
-
Deventer, Olanda
- Deventer Ziekenhuis
-
Contatto:
- Alinda Guitink
- Numero di telefono: +31 (570) 53 51 05
- Email: a.guitink@dz.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Frank ter Borg, MD
-
Eindhoven, Olanda
- Catharina Ziekenhuis
-
Contatto:
- Monique Monique van Dillen - Schilders
- Numero di telefono: +31 402399750
- Email: researchmdl@catharinaziekenhuis.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Ramon Michel Schreuder, MD
-
Groningen, Olanda, 9713 GZ
- Universitair Medisch Centrum Groningen
-
Contatto:
- Annika Dommering-Blankenstein
- Numero di telefono: +31 (050) 361 92 59
- Email: j.f.blankenstein@umcg.nl
-
Contatto:
- Wieke Holwerda
- Email: w.holwerda@umcg.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Wouter Nagengast, MD PhD
-
Haarlem, Olanda
- Spaarne Gasthuis
-
Hoorn, Olanda
- Dijklander Ziekenhuis
-
Contatto:
- Maisha van der Zon
- Numero di telefono: +31 229257823
- Email: DOC@dijklander.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Joris van den Broek, MD
-
Leiden, Olanda
- Leiden Universitair Medisch Centrum
-
Contatto:
- Jurjen Boonstra, MD PhD
- Numero di telefono: +31 71 526 35 75
- Email: j.j.boonstra@lumc.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Jurjen Boonstra, MD PhD
-
Nieuwegein, Olanda
- St. Antonius Ziekenhuis
-
Roermond, Olanda
- Laurentius Ziekenhuis
-
Contatto:
- Annette Meijer
- Numero di telefono: +31(475) 38 27 68
- Email: annette.meijer@lzr.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Jeroen Leijtens, MD
-
Rotterdam, Olanda, 3015 GD
- Erasmus Medisch Centrum
-
Contatto:
- Milko van Langen
- Numero di telefono: +31 107040572
- Email: m.vanlangen@erasmusmc.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Arjun Koch, MD PhD
-
The Hague, Olanda
- Haaglanden Medisch Centrum
-
Contatto:
- Angela van Egmond
- Numero di telefono: +31 88 979 43 07
- Email: angela.van.egmond@haaglandenmc.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Andreas Marinelli, MD PhD
-
Utrecht, Olanda, 3584 CX
- University Medical Center Utrecht
-
Contatto:
- Linda Wissenlink
- Numero di telefono: +31 088 75 56276
- Email: l.e.wisselink@umcutrecht.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Leon Moons, MD PhD
-
Zwolle, Olanda
- Isala
-
Contatto:
- Lieke Smeets
- Numero di telefono: +31 88 624 62 23
- Email: research.chirurgie@isala.nl
-
Investigatore principale:
- Erik van Westreenen, MD PhD
-
-
Criteri di partecipazione
Criteri di ammissibilità
Criteri di ammissibilità
Età idonea allo studio
Accetta volontari sani
Sessi ammissibili allo studio
Descrizione
Inclusion criteria:
To be eligible to participate in this study, a patient must meet all of the following criteria:
- Adult patients (≥ 18 years of age).
- Suspected rectal D-SMIC based on optical diagnosis using narrow-band imaging:
- Hiroshima C2/3, JNET 3, NICE III, Kudo Vn pit pattern.
- The presence of non-lifting together with features of superficial submucosal invasion (Hiroshima C1, JNET 2B, Kudo Vi pit pattern).
- MRI shows cT1-T2 invasion and minimum of 1 mm preserved muscularis propria.
- Tumour with its lower border situated on or below the level of the sigmoid take off as shown on rectal MRI.
- Staging rectal MRI confirms absence of suspicious malignant mesorectal lymph nodes, defined as mucinous lymph nodes, perirectal lymph nodes >9 mm in short-axis diameter, or ≥7 mm for lateral lymph nodes (classified as certain cN+), or 5-9 mm peri-rectal lymph nodes with at least 2 suspect morphological features: round shape, heterogeneity and/or irregular borders (classified as doubtful cN+).
- Staging rectal MRI confirms absence of tumour deposits.
- Staging rectal MRI confirms absence of extramural vascular invasion (EMVI).
Exclusion criteria:
A patient who meets one or more of the following criteria will be excluded from participation in this study:
- Lesions involving more than 50% of the circumference.
- Total lesion size larger than 6 cm.
- Prior endoscopic or surgical resection attempts of the tumour.
- Recurrent cancer after previous surgical or endoscopic local resection.
- Severe pre-existing faecal incontinence with impaired quality of life.
- Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) with previous inflammation of the rectum.
- Previous pelvic irradiation or neoadjuvant therapy.
- Poor general health that prevents the use of general anaesthesia.
- Inability or contraindication to undergo MRI scan.
- Concomitant malignancies or other severe medical conditions that, in the opinion of the multidisciplinary team (MDT), are likely to result in death within 5 years.
- AJCC stage II, III or IV CRC within the last 5 years or synchronous CRC.
- Inability to complete questionnaires or sign informed consent.
- Known pregnancy.
Piano di studio
Come è strutturato lo studio?
Dettagli di progettazione
- Scopo principale: Trattamento
- Assegnazione: Randomizzato
- Modello interventistico: Assegnazione parallela
- Mascheramento: Nessuno (etichetta aperta)
Numero di armi
Armi e interventi
Gruppo di partecipanti / ArmGruppo di partecipanti / Arm |
Intervento / TrattamentoIntervento / Trattamento |
|---|---|
|
Comparatore attivo: Endoscopic intermuscular dissection (EID)
A participant randomly allocated to the EID arm will undergo an EID procedure at one of the participating study centres. Pre-procedural preparation and perioperative management will follow the standard-of-care protocols. The EID procedure will be performed according to the procedure definition and study protocol. |
EID is an endoscopic local excision technique used for the resection of early-stage rectal tumours. The procedure uses a flexible endoscope to dissect between the inner (circular) and outer (longitudinal) muscles of the m. propria leaving the outer rectal wall layers intact. It is performed under conscious sedation by a gastroenterologist. |
|
Comparatore attivo: Transanal minimally invasive surgery (TAMIS)
A participant randomly allocated to the TAMIS arm will undergo a TAMIS procedure at one of the participating study centres. Participants will be prepared according to the standard-of-care protocol. TAMIS will be performed as a full-thickness approach according to the procedure protocol; however, for lesions located in areas with limited or absent mesorectal fat, a full-thickness excision should be avoided. In these cases, an intermuscular approach may be adopted. The planned dissection plane (full-thickness or intermuscular) will be determined by the study steering committee based on preoperative radiographic and endoscopic assessment. |
TAMIS is a minimally invasive transanal surgical technique used for the local excision of early-stage rectal tumours. A transanal platform is inserted into the anus to allow access with laparoscopic instruments. The procedure may be performed using a full-thickness or an intermuscular approach, based on tumour characteristics and surgical planning. The procedure is performed under general anesthesia by surgeons. |
Cosa sta misurando lo studio?
Misure di risultato primarie
Misure di risultato primarie
Misura del risultato |
Misura Descrizione |
Lasso di tempo |
|---|---|---|
|
Rate of complete R0 resection between TAMIS and EID procedures
Lasso di tempo: Assessed immediately after local excision procedure
|
The rate of complete R0 resection, defined as complete en-bloc resection with cancer free resection margins of >0.1mm, will be evaluated. |
Assessed immediately after local excision procedure
|
Misure di risultato secondarie
Misure di risultato secondarie
Misura del risultato |
Misura Descrizione |
Lasso di tempo |
|---|---|---|
|
Incidence of procedure-related adverse events
Lasso di tempo: Procedure-related adverse events will be recorded for 30 days post-procedure.
|
Procedure-related adverse events will be registered and recorded according to standard clinical practice in the Dutch Registration of Complications of Endoscopy (DRCE) or Dutch Surgical Colorectal Audit (DSCA). Details of all procedure-related complications within 30 days will be recorded in the eCRF and entered in ALEA database. |
Procedure-related adverse events will be recorded for 30 days post-procedure.
|
|
Postprocedural pain scores
Lasso di tempo: VAS scores will be recorded for 30 days post-procedure
|
Post-procedural recovery and pain will be assessed using a pain diary for the first 30 days following the procedure. Participants will record their daily pain intensity using a visual analogue scale (VAS), as well as their use of analgesic medication, until they report no pain for two consecutive days. |
VAS scores will be recorded for 30 days post-procedure
|
|
Recovery scores
Lasso di tempo: Assessed 30 days post-procedure
|
Post-procedural recovery will be assessed for the first 30 days following the procedure. Level of recovery, defined as the participant's ability to perform activities of daily living, will be recorded at on days 1, 3, 7, 14, and 30 post-procedure. |
Assessed 30 days post-procedure
|
|
Rate of curative local excisions for pT1sm2-3 rectal cancer
Lasso di tempo: Assessed immediately after local excision procedure
|
The rate of curative local excisions for pT1sm2-3 rectal cancer will be recorded. A curative local excision refers to pT1sm2-3 lesions with a complete R0 resection and the absence of additional histological risk factors. |
Assessed immediately after local excision procedure
|
|
Dissection plane evaluation
Lasso di tempo: Assessed immediately after local excision procedure
|
The rate of concordance between the definitive dissection plane and initially intended dissection plane prior to local excision (e.g., presence of longitudinal m. propria following an intended intermuscular dissection) will be evaluated. Only CRC pathologists trained within the PATCH study will assess the EID and TAMIS specimens to minimize interobserver variability. |
Assessed immediately after local excision procedure
|
|
Quality of local excision specimen
Lasso di tempo: Assessed immediately after local excision procedure
|
The quality of local excision specimens will be reviewed by a CRC pathologist for segment fragmentation, margin assessment, and the presence of muscularis propria underneath the invasive front (circular/longitudinal). Histological handling and evaluation of the resection specimen will be performed at participating centers according to standard care procedures. Only CRC pathologists trained within the PATCH study will handle EID and TAMIS specimens to minimize interobserver variability. |
Assessed immediately after local excision procedure
|
|
Postoperative adverse events
Lasso di tempo: Assessed for the first 30 days post-operatively
|
In the event that a total mesorectal excision (TME) is performed after local excision, post-operative adverse events (Clavien-Dindo classification) will be assessed for the first 30 days following TME. |
Assessed for the first 30 days post-operatively
|
|
TME specimen quality after EID vs TAMIS
Lasso di tempo: Assessed immediately after TME
|
In the event that a total mesorectal excision (TME) is performed after local excision, the quality of completion surgery will be systematically assessed. This includes TME specimen quality (Quirke classification). |
Assessed immediately after TME
|
|
Circumferential resection margin status following completion surgery
Lasso di tempo: Assessed immediately after TME
|
In the event that a total mesorectal excision (TME) is performed after local excision, the quality of completion surgery will be systematically assessed. This includes circumferential resection margin status. |
Assessed immediately after TME
|
|
Conversion rate to laparotomy
Lasso di tempo: Assessed immediately after TME
|
In the event that a total mesorectal excision (TME) is performed after local excision, the quality of completion surgery will be systematically assessed. This includes conversion rate to laparotomy. |
Assessed immediately after TME
|
|
Rate of non-restorative TME procedures
Lasso di tempo: Assessed immediately after TME
|
In the event that a total mesorectal excision (TME) is performed after local excision, the quality of completion surgery will be systematically assessed. This includes rate of non-restorative procedures. |
Assessed immediately after TME
|
|
Functional Outcomes
Lasso di tempo: Functional outcomes will be measured via LARS scores within a period of 12 months.
|
Functional outcomes will be measured using the validated Low Anterior Resection Syndrome (LARS) score at baseline, 1, 3, 6, and 12 months. The LARS score is 5-question survey tool used to measure bowel dysfunction after rectal cancer surgery. Total points range from 0 to 42, in which a higher scores indicate more severe symptoms and poor bowel functionality. |
Functional outcomes will be measured via LARS scores within a period of 12 months.
|
|
Health related quality of life (QLQ-C30)
Lasso di tempo: Questionnaires will be completed within a period of 3 years.
|
Health related Quality of Life (QoL) will be assessed using the validated Quality of Life Questionnaire - Core 30 (QLQ-C30) surveys. The QLQ-C30 contains 30 questions that measure the health-related quality of life of cancer patients. All of the scales and single-items range from 0 to 100. A higher score for the functioning scales and global health status implies a better level of functioning. Higher scores on the symptom and single-item scales indicate a higher level of symptoms. Questionnaires will be sent at baseline, 1, 3, 12, and 36 months. All questionnaires will be sent at predefined intervals electronically or collected on paper forms. |
Questionnaires will be completed within a period of 3 years.
|
|
Health related quality of life (QLQ-CR29)
Lasso di tempo: Surveys will be completed within a period of 3 years.
|
Health related Quality of Life (QoL) will be assessed using the validated Quality of Life Questionnaire - Colorectal Research 29 (QLQ-CR29). This survey contains 29 questions regarding burden of symptoms, side effects, body image, and sexual functioning. Scores scale from 0-100 with higher scores on symptom scales indicating a higher symptom burden, while higher scores on functional scales indicate better functionality. Questionnaires will be sent at baseline, 1, 3, 12, and 36 months. All questionnaires will be sent at predefined intervals electronically or collected on paper forms. |
Surveys will be completed within a period of 3 years.
|
|
Health related quality of life (EQ-5D-5L)
Lasso di tempo: Surveys will be completed within a period of 3 years.
|
Health-related quality of life (QoL) will be assessed using the validated EuroQol 5-Dimension 5-Level questionnaire (EQ-5D-5L). The EQ-5D-5L assesses health across five dimensions: mobility, self-care, usual activities, pain/discomfort, and anxiety/depression. Each dimension is rated on a five-level scale from 1 (no problems) to 5 (extreme problems), with higher scores indicating greater impairment in the respective health dimension. The EQ-5D-5L will be completed at baseline and at 1, 3, 12, and 36 months post-procedure. Questionnaires will be completed electronically or, where necessary, using paper forms. |
Surveys will be completed within a period of 3 years.
|
|
Rectal preservation and stoma free survival
Lasso di tempo: Following completion of procedure to end of follow-up at 3 years
|
The use of stoma and rates of rectal preservation will be measured within a 3 year period. |
Following completion of procedure to end of follow-up at 3 years
|
|
Cancer recurrence rates
Lasso di tempo: Cancer recurrences will be measured over a 3 year follow-up period
|
Intramural, locoregional, and distant 3-year cancer recurrence rates will be measured. |
Cancer recurrences will be measured over a 3 year follow-up period
|
|
Survival Rates
Lasso di tempo: Survival will be measured within the 3 year follow-up period.
|
Three-year disease-specific and overall survival will be measured within the 3 year follow-up period. |
Survival will be measured within the 3 year follow-up period.
|
|
Healthcare costs
Lasso di tempo: Healthcare costs will be measured from the time of enrollment to the end of the follow-up period at 3 years.
|
Healthcare costs will be measured using the validated iMCQ and iPCQ questionnaires at 1, 3, 12 and 36 months. |
Healthcare costs will be measured from the time of enrollment to the end of the follow-up period at 3 years.
|
Collaboratori e investigatori
Sponsor
Sponsor
Collaboratori
Collaboratori
Investigatori
Investigatori
- Investigatore principale: Barbara Bastiaansen, MD, Amsterdam University Medical Center
Studiare le date dei record
Studia le date principali
Inizio studio (Stimato)
Inizio studio
Completamento primario (Stimato)
Completamento primario
Completamento dello studio (Stimato)
Completamento dello studio
Date di iscrizione allo studio
Primo inviato
Primo inviato
Primo inviato che soddisfa i criteri di controllo qualità
Primo inviato che soddisfa i criteri di controllo qualità
Primo Inserito (Effettivo)
Primo Inserito
Aggiornamenti dei record di studio
Ultimo aggiornamento pubblicato (Effettivo)
Ultimo aggiornamento pubblicato
Ultimo aggiornamento inviato che soddisfa i criteri QC
Ultimo aggiornamento inviato che soddisfa i criteri QC
Ultimo verificato
Ultimo verificato
Maggiori informazioni
Termini relativi a questo studio
Parole chiave
Termini MeSH pertinenti aggiuntivi
- Neoplasie per sede
- Neoplasie
- Malattie intestinali
- Neoplasie gastrointestinali
- Neoplasie dell'apparato digerente
- Malattie dell'apparato digerente
- Malattie gastrointestinali
- Neoplasie colorettali
- Neoplasie intestinali
- Malattie del retto
- Neoplasie Rettali
- Tecniche e procedure diagnostiche
- Diagnosi
- Procedure chirurgiche, operative
- Procedure chirurgiche minimamente invasive
- Tecniche diagnostiche, chirurgiche
- Endoscopia, gastrointestinale
- Endoscopia, sistema digestivo
- Endoscopia
- Procedure chirurgiche del sistema digestivo
- Natural Orifice Endoscopic Surgery
- Proctoscopy
- Transanal Endoscopic Surgery
Altri numeri di identificazione dello studio
Altri numeri di identificazione dello studio
- NL-010393
Informazioni su farmaci e dispositivi, documenti di studio
Studia un prodotto farmaceutico regolamentato dalla FDA degli Stati Uniti
Studia un dispositivo regolamentato dalla FDA degli Stati Uniti
Queste informazioni sono state recuperate direttamente dal sito web clinicaltrials.gov senza alcuna modifica. In caso di richieste di modifica, rimozione o aggiornamento dei dettagli dello studio, contattare register@clinicaltrials.gov. Non appena verrà implementata una modifica su clinicaltrials.gov, questa verrà aggiornata automaticamente anche sul nostro sito web .