The Biology of Resilience

The Biology of Resilience: Oxytocin, Social Relationships and Health

Positive social relationships have consistently been associated with better health, although the neurobiological underpinnings of these observed effects remain largely unknown. The overall goal of the proposed work is to explore novel biological pathways that may explain how social relationships influence health. Recent theorizing suggests that the oxytocin system may underlie some of the observed beneficial effects. Four hypotheses will be examined:

1. Oxytocin ameliorates the deleterious neuroendocrine, cardiovascular, and subjective effects of stress.
2. Oxytocin and social support have similar and additive stress-buffering effects.
3. Effects of oxytocin are evident among younger and older adults.
4. Effects of oxytocin are stronger in women vs men.

Study Overview

• Status: Completed
• Conditions: Oxytocin; Placebo
• Intervention / Treatment: Drug: intranasal oxytocin; Behavioral: Social support; Behavioral: No Social Support; Drug: Placebo

Detailed Description

Positive social relationships have consistently been associated with better health, although the neurobiological underpinnings of these observed effects are not well understood. Valuable insight may be gained by a life course perspective as it is becoming increasingly apparent that early life social experiences are crucially related to later life functioning and well-being. The overall goal of the proposed work is to explore novel biological pathways that help to explain how social relationships influence health. Recent theorizing on the biology relating positive social and emotional factors to health and patterns of resilience suggest that the oxytocin system may underlie some of the observed beneficial effects. Historically, most work on the oxytocin system in humans has been tied to reproductive outcomes (e.g., lactation), with more limited work on children and young adults. A growing body of experimental research with animals suggests that early in life, oxytocin not only creates powerful social bonds between a mother and child but may also stimulate growth and restorative processes as well as buffer deleterious stress-related neuroendocrine activation throughout the life course. Moreover, the animal literature has suggested that oxytocin is more potent in the presence of higher estrogen levels, leading investigators to hypothesize that effects of oxytocin are stronger in women than men, but few studies have tested this hypothesis in humans. A better understanding of the inter-relationships between oxytocin, social relationships, stress, and health will be gained by examining these factors in a controlled laboratory setting. The immediate goal of this research is to determine whether oxytocin plays a critical role in determining neuroendocrine, cardiovascular, and subjective responses to stress across age and gender, and to examine the effects of oxytocin in relation to those of social support. To achieve these goals, experimental research is proposed to examine the effects of exogenously administered (intranasal) oxytocin on psychological and physiological outcomes, under conditions of stress. The specific aims of this exploratory project are to test the following hypotheses:

1. Oxytocin ameliorates the deleterious neuroendocrine, cardiovascular, and subjective effects of stress.
2. Oxytocin and social support have similar and additive stress-buffering effects.
3. Effects of oxytocin are stronger in women versus men.
4. Effects of oxytocin are similar across a range of younger and older adult ages.

Hypotheses will be tested via a placebo-controlled double blind study using a sample of healthy men and women recruited from the community (overall n = 320). The proposed experimental study will consider oxytocin effects on a range of outcomes. These include autonomic reactivity as measured by blood pressure responses and high frequency heart rate variability (measure of vagal tone). Stress-related cardiovascular phenotypes as characterized by the patterning of ventricle contractility, vascular resistance, and cardiac output will also be assessed. Other outcomes include measures of neuroendocrine effects as measured by levels of cortisol and dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) hormone, subjective distress and positive affect. Participants will be randomly assigned to receive either exogenous oxytocin or placebo. They will undergo a social stress manipulation with or without social support (randomly assigned), and outcome measures will be obtained at multiple times during the experimental procedure. The experiment will test whether effects of oxytocin and social support are similar and additive, and will also compare effects of oxytocin and social support across men and women of varying ages. This multidisciplinary study uses a biobehavioral framework to examine interactions between psychological, social, and biological levels of functioning, and is informed by theories of how key early life exposures may impact health over the life course. The provision of an R21 award for this work will facilitate novel research that could have a major impact on our understanding of whether and how oxytocin influences responses to stress in humans. The proposed exploratory research will lay the groundwork for the submission of an R01 grant proposal that will have greater resources for addressing both the questions that cannot be addressed with this more limited mechanism as well as new questions that will undoubtedly arise. Ultimately we expect this project will provide a solid platform from which to launch a larger program of research aimed at identifying how positive social and emotional experiences influence adult health and longevity. A neurobiological understanding of resilience can inform efforts for both prevention and intervention of diseases or problems common in later life.

• Study Type: Interventional
• Enrollment (Actual): 270
• Phase: Not Applicable

Contacts and Locations

Study Locations

• United States
  • Massachusetts
    • Boston, Massachusetts, United States, 02115
      • Harvard School of Public Health

Participation Criteria

Eligibility Criteria

• Ages Eligible for Study: 22 years to 65 years (Adult, Older Adult)
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes
• Genders Eligible for Study: All

Description

Inclusion Criteria:

• age 22-65, BMI < 30, healthy, English-speaking, 9th grade reading level.

Exclusion Criteria:

• any known medical condition (including mental disorders) or on any type of medication
• high levels of social anxiety
• smokers
• high rates of alcohol or drug use
• pregnant or suspected pregnant
• breastfeeding
• blood pressures > 140/90 mm Hg
• subject does not have a close friend available to participate in the study with him/her

Study Plan

How is the study designed?

Design Details

• Primary Purpose: Basic Science
• Allocation: Randomized
• Interventional Model: Factorial Assignment
• Masking: Triple

Number of Arms

6

Arms and Interventions

Participant Group / Arm	Intervention / Treatment
Experimental: Oxytocin; One primary experimental manipulation is the receipt of intranasal oxytocin vs placebo spray prior to participation in a psychosocial stress protocol	Drug: intranasal oxytocin; The aqueous form of oxytocin (oxytocin injection, synthetic) in 10 ml vials is inserted into a spray bottle. The spray bottle is calibrated so that emptying the spray bottle results in delivering 24 IU of oxytocin. No dilution of the original aqueous form of the oxytocin is necessary. 24 IU of oxytocin will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after 24 IUs of oxytocin have been administered. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes; Other Names: Pitocin; Behavioral: Social support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. If instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses, participants are joined by their support partners join participants at the start of the stress exposure. The social support condition includes a number of strategies designed to standardize the type of support available to participants across individuals.; Behavioral: No Social Support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. They are then instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses) with them, or to come alone. If they come to the laboratory without a friend, they engage in all the laboratory procedures without a friend present.
Placebo Comparator: Placebo; The comparison condition for receipt of oxytocin is receipt of a saline intranasal spray	Behavioral: Social support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. If instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses, participants are joined by their support partners join participants at the start of the stress exposure. The social support condition includes a number of strategies designed to standardize the type of support available to participants across individuals.; Behavioral: No Social Support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. They are then instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses) with them, or to come alone. If they come to the laboratory without a friend, they engage in all the laboratory procedures without a friend present.; Drug: Placebo; Participants in the placebo condition receive an equivalent amount of saline for intranasal spray administration. The placebo will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after the full amount in the spray bottle has been used. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes
Experimental: Social Support; Participants bring a friend to the laboratory who sits with them while they engage in the stress protocol tasks	Drug: intranasal oxytocin; The aqueous form of oxytocin (oxytocin injection, synthetic) in 10 ml vials is inserted into a spray bottle. The spray bottle is calibrated so that emptying the spray bottle results in delivering 24 IU of oxytocin. No dilution of the original aqueous form of the oxytocin is necessary. 24 IU of oxytocin will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after 24 IUs of oxytocin have been administered. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes; Other Names: Pitocin; Behavioral: Social support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. If instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses, participants are joined by their support partners join participants at the start of the stress exposure. The social support condition includes a number of strategies designed to standardize the type of support available to participants across individuals.; Drug: Placebo; Participants in the placebo condition receive an equivalent amount of saline for intranasal spray administration. The placebo will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after the full amount in the spray bottle has been used. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes
Placebo Comparator: No Social Support; Individuals in this condition do not have a friend present while they are engaging in the laboratory protocol.	Drug: intranasal oxytocin; The aqueous form of oxytocin (oxytocin injection, synthetic) in 10 ml vials is inserted into a spray bottle. The spray bottle is calibrated so that emptying the spray bottle results in delivering 24 IU of oxytocin. No dilution of the original aqueous form of the oxytocin is necessary. 24 IU of oxytocin will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after 24 IUs of oxytocin have been administered. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes; Other Names: Pitocin; Behavioral: No Social Support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. They are then instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses) with them, or to come alone. If they come to the laboratory without a friend, they engage in all the laboratory procedures without a friend present.; Drug: Placebo; Participants in the placebo condition receive an equivalent amount of saline for intranasal spray administration. The placebo will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after the full amount in the spray bottle has been used. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes
Other: Female Gender; Effects of oxytocin and social support are examined among women versus men	Drug: intranasal oxytocin; The aqueous form of oxytocin (oxytocin injection, synthetic) in 10 ml vials is inserted into a spray bottle. The spray bottle is calibrated so that emptying the spray bottle results in delivering 24 IU of oxytocin. No dilution of the original aqueous form of the oxytocin is necessary. 24 IU of oxytocin will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after 24 IUs of oxytocin have been administered. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes; Other Names: Pitocin; Behavioral: Social support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. If instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses, participants are joined by their support partners join participants at the start of the stress exposure. The social support condition includes a number of strategies designed to standardize the type of support available to participants across individuals.; Behavioral: No Social Support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. They are then instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses) with them, or to come alone. If they come to the laboratory without a friend, they engage in all the laboratory procedures without a friend present.; Drug: Placebo; Participants in the placebo condition receive an equivalent amount of saline for intranasal spray administration. The placebo will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after the full amount in the spray bottle has been used. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes
Other: Male Gender; Consider effects of oxytocin and social support in men versus women	Drug: intranasal oxytocin; The aqueous form of oxytocin (oxytocin injection, synthetic) in 10 ml vials is inserted into a spray bottle. The spray bottle is calibrated so that emptying the spray bottle results in delivering 24 IU of oxytocin. No dilution of the original aqueous form of the oxytocin is necessary. 24 IU of oxytocin will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after 24 IUs of oxytocin have been administered. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes; Other Names: Pitocin; Behavioral: Social support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. If instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses, participants are joined by their support partners join participants at the start of the stress exposure. The social support condition includes a number of strategies designed to standardize the type of support available to participants across individuals.; Behavioral: No Social Support; Prior to coming to the laboratory, participants are randomly assigned to one of two conditions, requiring them to appear alone or accompanied by a partner. They are then instructed to bring a same-sex close friend (excluding spouses) with them, or to come alone. If they come to the laboratory without a friend, they engage in all the laboratory procedures without a friend present.; Drug: Placebo; Participants in the placebo condition receive an equivalent amount of saline for intranasal spray administration. The placebo will be administered at one time only during the procedure. Approximately half the dose will be sprayed into each nostril. Administration will stop after the full amount in the spray bottle has been used. Duration of administration is anticipated to be 2-5 minutes

What is the study measuring?

Primary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure	Measure Description	Time Frame
Systolic Blood Pressure Change From Baseline to Second Stress Task Experience - Autonomic Stress Response Measure	Systolic blood pressure (SBP)is connected with reaction to exposure to stress. Systolic blood pressure is collected at baseline and after nasal spray administration/directly before stress tasks; it represents anticipatory stress reaction. This measure represents the difference between baseline and pre-task systolic blood pressure values. A greater difference score represents an increase from baseline in systolic blood pressure during the pre-task, and so a larger difference score represents higher reactivity. A lower difference score, or negative difference score, indicates a lower increase, or even decrease, from baseline in systolic blood pressure during the pre-task and reflects less reactivity. Reactivity is associated with increased risk of developing hypertension. Range of baseline/pre-count differences in SBP: -11 to 37.7	within 2 hours of treatment
Difference of Pre-count and Baseline Self-reported Negative Affect (Using Negative Sub-scale of Positive and Negative Affect Schedule (PANAS) Measure).	Based on 20-item Positive and Negative Affect Schedule (PANAS) which comprises two mood scales, positive affect and negative affect. Each item is rated on a 5-point scale ranging from (1 = very slightly or not at all) to (5 = extremely) to indicate how the respondent felt at the moment the question was asked. Here, we've used the negative affect sub-scale which consists of the sum of the 10 negative affect items, with a possible range of 10 (least negative affect) to 50 (most negative affect). This score was measured at baseline (study range: 10 to 29) and directly before stress exposure (study range: 10 to 37), and the reported value is the difference between these two scores (range of differences: -13 to 26). It estimates negative affect due to anticipatory stress. The value is the difference between the pre-stress measure and baseline measure, therefore a larger number for the difference means a bigger increase in negative affect due to anticipatory stress, and is a worse outcome.	2 hours
Speech Threat and Challenge	Measure of threat and challenge calculated from observation of non-verbal behavioral cues during stress exposure. Threat (negative reaction) results when an individual does not feel that he or she has sufficient resources to complete a task or manage a difficult situation. Its reverse, challenge (positive reaction), occurs when an individual perceives that he or she has sufficient resources. Independent observers used videotapes of behavior during the stress tasks and rated participants on 7 point scales for 11 challenge-related behaviors (comfortable, confident, enthusiastic, clear, alert, high level of eye contact, etc), and for 8 threat-related behaviors (agitation, rigid posture, speech disfluency, etc). Challenge scores were averaged, and threat scores averaged then reverse-scored. The mean of challenge and reversed threat scores comprise the score used here. Range: 1.1 to 6.1, with higher scores representing more challenge orientation and reflecting a better outcome.	2 hours

Collaborators and Investigators

• Sponsor: Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH)
• Collaborators: Brigham and Women's Hospital
• Investigators: Principal Investigator: Laura D Kubzansky, PhD, Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH)

Publications and helpful links

General Publications

• Kubzansky LD, Mendes WB, Appleton A, Block J, Adler GK. Protocol for an experimental investigation of the roles of oxytocin and social support in neuroendocrine, cardiovascular, and subjective responses to stress across age and gender. BMC Public Health. 2009 Dec 21;9:481. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-9-481.
• Kubzansky LD, Mendes WB, Appleton AA, Block J, Adler GK. A heartfelt response: Oxytocin effects on response to social stress in men and women. Biol Psychol. 2012 Apr;90(1):1-9. doi: 10.1016/j.biopsycho.2012.02.010. Epub 2012 Feb 23. Erratum In: Biol Psychol. 2013 Feb;92(2):97.

Study record dates

Study Major Dates

• Study Start: February 1, 2009
• Primary Completion (Actual): April 1, 2012
• Study Completion (Actual): April 1, 2012

Study Registration Dates

• First Submitted: November 10, 2009
• First Submitted That Met QC Criteria: November 10, 2009
• First Posted (Estimate): November 11, 2009

Study Record Updates

• Last Update Posted (Estimate): November 26, 2012
• Last Update Submitted That Met QC Criteria: October 24, 2012
• Last Verified: October 1, 2012

More Information

Terms related to this study

• Keywords: Stress; Oxytocin; Social Support; Resilience
• Additional Relevant MeSH Terms: Physiological Effects of Drugs; Reproductive Control Agents; Oxytocics; Oxytocin
• Other Study ID Numbers: 1R21AG030632-01A2 (U.S. NIH Grant/Contract)