Heart Rate Variability-guided Training in Cardiac Rehabilitation

Is Heart Rate Variability-guided Training Superior to Predefined Training for Improving Parasympathetic Activity and Aerobic Functional Capacity in Coronary Artery Disease Patients?

Background: Previous studies have reported that heart rate variability (HRV)-guided training is a better option for improving autonomic function and aerobic capacity (i.e., oxygen uptake and power output at second ventilatory threshold and maximal exercise) during a cardiopulmonary exercise test compared to predefined training in sedentary and physically active healthy people. Nevertheless, none of these previous studies have been carried out with coronary artery disease (CAD) patients.

Methods: A total of 23 patients with CAD were divided into HRV-guided training group (HRV-G; n = 11) and predefined training group (PRE-G; n = 12). All patients trained three days a week for eight weeks (18 sessions). Patients allocated in the PRED-G carried out a previously established cardiac rehabilitation programme, combining sessions of moderate and high intensity, while patients allocated in the HRV-G carried out sessions of moderate or high intensity on the basis of their daily HRV assessments. The weekly averaged and isolated parasympathetic-related HRV indices, heart rate recovery, resting heart rate, and aerobic capacity were assessed before and after of the training programme.

Study Overview

• Status: Completed
• Conditions: Coronary Artery Disease
• Intervention / Treatment: Other: Aerobic training cardiac rehabilitation program

Detailed Description

This study was a parallel-group, double-blind, randomised controlled trial. This study was approved by the ethical committee of the local University and was conducted conforming to the recommendations of the Declaration of Helsinki. Eligible patients were men and women with low-risk and age ≥ 18 years, who had experienced an acute myocardial infarction, angina pectoris, had undergone revascularisation (percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty or coronary artery bypass grafting) or coronary heart disease was documented by angiography, up to one year before to the enrolment in the study. Exclusion criteria included unstable angina, atrial fibrillation, cardiac implantable electronic devices, complex ventricular arrhythmias, uncontrolled hypertension, conditions limiting participation in exercise training and/or symptom-limited cardiopulmonary exercise test at pre-intervention. Before taking part in the study, patients were interviewed and signed a written informed consent. The patients were randomly allocated to a predefined training group (PRED-G; n = 12) or heart rate variability (HRV)-guided training group (HRV-G; n = 11).Before to start the study protocol, patients were instructed to properly carry out day-to-day HRV measurements. The study protocol was divided into two periods: a 2-week baseline period (BP) and a 6-week training period (TP). Before and after TP, baseline assessment week (PRE) and final assessment week (POST) were conducted, respectively. The variables/tests assessed/included in the assessment weeks were: cardiopulmonary exercise test, autonomic function, body composition, blood analysis, quality of life and dietary intake. Assessments were carried out in the same sequence and at the same period of the day. Patients and assessors recording the outcome measurements were blinded to the group allocations. Throughout the 6-week TP, patients allocated to PRED-G carried out a predefined training program, while patients that were assigned to HRV-G trained based on day-to-day HRV measurements.

• Study Type: Interventional
• Enrollment (Actual): 23
• Phase: Not Applicable

Contacts and Locations

Study Locations

• Spain
  • Alicante
    • Elche, Alicante, Spain, 03202
      • Universidad Miguel Hernández

Participation Criteria

Eligibility Criteria

• Ages Eligible for Study: 18 years and older (Adult, Older Adult)
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No
• Genders Eligible for Study: All

Description

Inclusion Criteria:

• Patients who had experienced an acute myocardial infarction up to one year before to the enrolment in the study
• Patients who had experienced an angina pectoris up to one year before to the enrolment in the study
• Patients who had undergone revascularisation (percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty or coronary artery bypass grafting), up to one year before to the enrolment in the study
• Clinical diagnosis of coronary heart disease documented by angiography, up to one year before to the enrolment in the study

Exclusion Criteria:

• Unstable angina
• Atrial fibrillation
• Cardiac implantable electronic devices
• Complex ventricular arrhythmias
• Uncontrolled hypertension
• Conditions limiting participation in exercise training
• Symptom-limited cardiopulmonary exercise test at PRE

Study Plan

How is the study designed?

Design Details

• Primary Purpose: Treatment
• Allocation: Randomized
• Interventional Model: Parallel Assignment
• Masking: Double

Number of Arms

2

Arms and Interventions

Participant Group / Arm	Intervention / Treatment
Experimental: Heart rate variability-guided training group; Patients allocated to heart rate variability-guided training group trained 3 days a week for 6 weeks. These patients carried out moderate continuous traininig sessions or high intensity interval training sessions based on their daily heart rate variability assessments follwing a decision schema.	Other: Aerobic training cardiac rehabilitation program; Moderate continuous training sessions and high intensity interval training sessiones were used to carried out aerobic training
Active Comparator: Predefined training group; Patients allocated to predefined training group also trained 3 days a week for 6 weeks. Nonetheless, these patients performed a predefined training program regarless of their parasympathetic modulation status.	Other: Aerobic training cardiac rehabilitation program; Moderate continuous training sessions and high intensity interval training sessiones were used to carried out aerobic training

What is the study measuring?

Primary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure	Measure Description	Time Frame
Change from PRE in workload at 6 weeks (POST)	A cardiopulmonary exercise test was performed using a medically supervised maximal graded cycle ergometer exercise test (Excite Bike Med, Technogym, Cesana, Italy) at the Miguel Hernandez University of Elche (Spain). The workload was obtained in Watts at the exercise peak and second ventilatory threshold. An experienced exercise physiologist together with a cardiologist supervised all the cardiorespiratory tests.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in absolute oxygen uptake at 6 weeks (POST)	A cardiopulmonary exercise test was performed using a medically supervised maximal graded cycle ergometer exercise test (Excite Bike Med, Technogym, Cesana, Italy) at the Miguel Hernandez University of Elche (Spain). Respiratory gas exchange was measured by MasterScreen CPX (Jaeger, Hoechberg, Germany). The oxygen uptake (VO2), expressed in absolute values (mL/min), was obtained at exercise peak, second ventilatory threshold and in resting condition. An experienced exercise physiologist together with a cardiologist supervised all the cardiorespiratory tests.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in relative oxygen uptake at 6 weeks (POST)	A cardiopulmonary exercise test was performed using a medically supervised maximal graded cycle ergometer exercise test (Excite Bike Med, Technogym, Cesana, Italy) at the Miguel Hernandez University of Elche (Spain). Respiratory gas exchange was measured by MasterScreen CPX (Jaeger, Hoechberg, Germany). The oxygen uptake (VO2), expressed in relative values to each individual's body weight (mL/kg/min), was obtained at exercise peak, second ventilatory threshold and in resting condition. An experienced exercise physiologist together with a cardiologist supervised all the cardiorespiratory tests.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in heart rate at 6 weeks (POST)	A cardiopulmonary exercise test was performed using a medically supervised maximal graded cycle ergometer exercise test (Excite Bike Med, Technogym, Cesana, Italy) at the Miguel Hernandez University of Elche (Spain). The heart rate (HR) was monitored continuously using a 12-lead electrocardiogram (Jaeger, Hoechberg, Germany). The HR was measured in beats per minute at exercise peak, second ventilatory threshold and in resting condition. An experienced exercise physiologist together with a cardiologist supervised all the cardiorespiratory tests.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in systolic blood pressure at 6 weeks (POST)	A cardiopulmonary exercise test was performed using a medically supervised maximal graded cycle ergometer exercise test (Excite Bike Med, Technogym, Cesana, Italy) at the Miguel Hernandez University of Elche (Spain). A digital sphygmomanometer (Tango+, Suntech, USA) was used for the assessment of systolic blood pressure. The systolic blood pressure was measured in millimetres of mercury at the exercise peak and in resting condition. An experienced exercise physiologist together with a cardiologist supervised all the cardiorespiratory tests.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in diastolic blood pressure at 6 weeks (POST)	A cardiopulmonary exercise test was performed using a medically supervised maximal graded cycle ergometer exercise test (Excite Bike Med, Technogym, Cesana, Italy) at the Miguel Hernandez University of Elche (Spain). A digital sphygmomanometer (Tango+, Suntech, USA) was used for the assessment of diastolic blood pressure. The diastolic blood pressure was measured in millimetres of mercury at the exercise peak and in resting condition. An experienced exercise physiologist together with a cardiologist supervised all the cardiorespiratory tests.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in isolated heart rate variability at 6 weeks (POST)	Isolated heart rate variability (HRV) assessments were performed in a quiet room with an average temperature of 22ᵒC. Polar H7 chest strap (Polar Electro OY, Kempele, Finland) and Elite HRV app (Perrotta, Jeklin, Hives, Meanwell, & Warburton, 2017) were used to capture HRV measurements. Patients were informed to avoid talking and sleeping, controlling breathing pace to 12 breaths per min. The length of the recording was 20 min, and the last 5 min was selected to calculate HRV indexes. Kubios HRV Software 2.0 for Windows (The Biomedical Signal Analysis Group, Kuopio, Finland) was used to analyse time and frequency domain indices in absolute and normalised units.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in averaged heart rate variability at 6 weeks (POST)	All patients were instructed to assess their heart rate variability (HRV) in the morning at home every day throughout the entire study. The HRV recordings were attained via a photoplethysmography smartphone application (HRV4Ttraining) previously validated (Daniel J Plews et al., 2017). HRV assess were done at rest, as patients lay supine for 90 s with spontaneous breathing in a semi-dark room, and the las 60 s were capture. Day-to-day HRV values across assessment weeks (PRE and POST) were averaged to obtain a 7-day weekly averaged HRV value.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), after waking up
Change from PRE in heart rate recovery at 6 weeks (POST)	A cardiopulmonary exercise test was performed using a medically supervised maximal graded cycle ergometer exercise test (Excite Bike Med, Technogym, Cesana, Italy) at the Miguel Hernandez University of Elche (Spain). The heart rate (HR) was monitored continuously using a 12-lead electrocardiogram (Jaeger, Hoechberg, Germany). After the exercise peak, a 3-min cool-down at 10 W was performed. The reduction in HR from immediately exercise peak to the HR after 1 and 2 min was defined as HR recovery (HRR) 1 min and HRR 2 min, respectively. An experienced exercise physiologist together with a cardiologist supervised all the cardiorespiratory tests.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day

Secondary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure	Measure Description	Time Frame
Change from PRE in body mass index at 6 weeks (POST)	Body mass index (BMI) was calculated according to the formula: total weight in kilograms divided by squared height in meters (kg/m2). All anthropometrical variables were measured by a Level 2 anthropometrist certified by the International Society for the Advance of Kinanthropometry (ISAK).	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in total body mass at 6 weeks (POST)	The total body mass of each participant was measured in kilograms using a digital scale (Tanita, TBF 300 A, Tokyo, Japan). All anthropometrical variables were measured by a Level 2 anthropometrist certified by the International Society for the Advance of Kinanthropometry (ISAK).	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in breadths at 6 weeks (POST)	The breadths of each participant were measured with a Holtain bicondylar calliper (Holtain, UK). The following four breadths were measured: humerus, wrist, femur, and ankle. All anthropometrical variables were measured by a Level 2 anthropometrist certified by the International Society for the Advance of Kinanthropometry (ISAK).	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in girths at 6 weeks (POST)	The total girths of each participant were measured with a metallic non-extensible tape (Lufkin, USA). The following four girths were measured: relaxed arm, flexed and tensed arm, thigh, and medial calf. All anthropometrical variables were measured by a Level 2 anthropometrist certified by the International Society for the Advance of Kinanthropometry (ISAK).	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in skinfolds at 6 weeks (POST)	The skinfolds of each participant were measured with a Holtain Tanner/Whitehouse skinfold calliper (Holtain, UK). Eight skinfolds were also measured: triceps, biceps, subscapular, ileocrestal, supraspinale, abdominal, thigh, and medial calf. All anthropometrical variables were measured by a Level 2 anthropometrist certified by the International Society for the Advance of Kinanthropometry (ISAK).	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in bone mass at 6 weeks (POST)	The percentage of bone mass of each participant was calculated according to Martin's equation. All anthropometrical variables were measured by a Level 2 anthropometrist certified by the International Society for the Advance of Kinanthropometry (ISAK).	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in body fat mass at 6 weeks (POST)	The percentage of body fat mass of each participant was calculated using Durnin-Womersley equation. In addition, the sums of the eight skinfolds were considered for fat content calculations. All anthropometrical variables were measured by a Level 2 anthropometrist certified by the International Society for the Advance of Kinanthropometry (ISAK).	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in muscle mass at 6 weeks (POST)	The percentage of muscle mass of each participant was calculated from Lee's equation. All anthropometrical variables were measured by a Level 2 anthropometrist certified by the International Society for the Advance of Kinanthropometry (ISAK).	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in glucose at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Glucose was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in urea at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Urea was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in creatinine at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Creatinine was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in uric acid at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Uric acid was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in LDH at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. LDH was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in creatine kinase at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Creatine kinase was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in sodium at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Sodium was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in potassium at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Potassium was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in cholesterol at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Cholesterol was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in triglyerides at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Triglycerides were measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in HDL-C at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. HDL-C was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in LDL-C at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. LDL-C was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in haemoglobin A1c at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Haemoglobin A1c was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in platelet at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Platelet was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in red blood cells at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Red blood cells were measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in haemoglobin at 6 weeks (POST)	Blood samples were obtained from the median cubital vein at PRE and POST after at least a 10-hour fast and 48 h before the test and without performing exercise in that period. Venipuncture took place in the Vinalopó-Salud Hospital of Elche (Spain) and was carried out by a nurse. Haemoglobin was measured using standard methods.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM
Change from PRE in quality of life at 6 weeks (POST)	The MacNew heart disease health-related quality of life (HRQL) instrument was used as a disease-specific health-related quality of life questionnaire. MacNew has been proved to be a valid and reliable questionnaire applicable to patients with coronary artery disease. The MacNew consists of 27 items that fall into three domains (a 13-item physical limitations domain scale, a 14-item emotional function domain scale, and a 13-item social function domain scale). The maximum possible score in any domain is 7 (high HRQL) and the minimum is 1 (poor HRQL).	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day
Change from PRE in dietary intake at 6 weeks (POST)	Patients recorded food and beverage consumption during 4 consecutive days, including Sunday, before and after the intervention. Data from records were analyzed using the ST-Nutrition software (Servitux, Elche, Spain). Macro- and micronutrient intakes were evaluated paying attention to recommendations performed by the Portfolio dietary pattern for the National Cholesterol Education Program (NECP) Step II.	Baseline (PRE) and at 6 weeks (POST), at the same period of the day

Collaborators and Investigators

• Sponsor: Universidad Miguel Hernandez de Elche

Study record dates

Study Major Dates

• Study Start (Actual): October 1, 2018
• Primary Completion (Actual): December 23, 2018
• Study Completion (Actual): July 30, 2019

Study Registration Dates

• First Submitted: May 20, 2021
• First Submitted That Met QC Criteria: June 10, 2021
• First Posted (Actual): June 18, 2021

Study Record Updates

• Last Update Posted (Actual): June 18, 2021
• Last Update Submitted That Met QC Criteria: June 10, 2021
• Last Verified: June 1, 2021

More Information

Terms related to this study

• Keywords: Cardiac rehabilitation; Cardiorespiratory fitness; Cardiac vagal modulation; Heart rate variability
• Additional Relevant MeSH Terms: Heart Diseases; Cardiovascular Diseases; Vascular Diseases; Arteriosclerosis; Arterial Occlusive Diseases; Coronary Artery Disease; Myocardial Ischemia; Coronary Disease
• Other Study ID Numbers: 2017.165.E.OEP

Plan for Individual participant data (IPD)

• Plan to Share Individual Participant Data (IPD)?: Undecided

Drug and device information, study documents

• Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated drug product: No
• Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated device product: No
• product manufactured in and exported from the U.S.: No