Comparison of the Effectiveness of Different Exercise Types in Individuals with Chronic Neck Pain

Comparison of the Effectiveness of Dynamic Isometric, Static Isometric and Craniocervical Flexor Exercise Training in Individuals with Chronic Neck Pain

The aim of this study is to compare the effectiveness of craniocervical flexion, static and dynamic isometric exercise training applied with a conventional physiotherapy program in individuals with chronic neck pain.

Study Overview

• Status: Recruiting
• Conditions: Chronic Neck Pain
• Intervention / Treatment: Other: Conventional Treatment Group; Other: Craniocervical Flexion Exercise Group; Other: Dynamic Isometric Exercise Group; Other: Static Isometric Exercise Group

Detailed Description

Neck pain is a significant musculoskeletal problem that is frequently encountered in society. Pain that cannot be diagnosed with a specific pathology is called "nonspecific" and pain that continues for more than three months is called "chronic pain". Chronic nonspecific neck pain has negative effects on function and quality of life. The importance of the exercise approach in the treatment of neck pain is quite great. Craniocervical flexion and static isometric exercises are frequently used in individuals with chronic neck pain. However, there are very few studies that include dynamic isometric exercises. The aim of this study is to compare the effectiveness of craniocervical flexion, static and dynamic isometric exercise training applied with a conventional physiotherapy program in individuals with chronic neck pain. The intervention groups of the study are deep cervical flexion exercise training, dynamic isometric exercise training and static isometric exercise training and electrotherapy group. The craniocervical flexion exercise training group will receive deep cervical flexor muscle training with Pressure Biofeedback, the dynamic isometric exercise group will receive exercise training with Thera-band, and the static isometric exercise group will receive neck isometric exercises. The electrotherapy group will receive hotpack, tens, and ultrasound applications. At the beginning and end of the study, pain, disability, posture, muscle strength, endurance, range of motion, and body awareness will be assessed in all individuals.TENS (Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation) will be applied to all groups for 20 minutes with a TENS device at a strength of 10-30 mA and a frequency of 80 Hz. A pair of surface electrodes will be placed on the painful area of the neck. The intensity of TENS will be adjusted according to the patient's sensory thresholds so that they are not disturbed by a numbness sensation. After TENS, continuous ultrasound will be applied to the cervical region to produce thermal effects. The intensity will be 1.5 W/cm² and the duration will be 5 minutes. Hotpack will be applied to the trapezius muscle for 10 minutes. Chin tuck exercise will be applied to the cervical region.

• Study Type: Interventional
• Enrollment (Estimated): 48
• Phase: Not Applicable

Contacts and Locations

• Study Contact: Name: Ayşen Canan Pakeloğlu, Physiotherapist; Phone Number: +905059102642; Email: aysencanan95@gmail.com

Study Locations

• Turkey
  • Menteşe
    • Mugla, Menteşe, Turkey, 48000
      • Recruiting
      • Mugla Education and Research Hospital
      • Contact: Ayşen Canan Pakeloğlu, Physiotherapist; Phone Number: +905059102642; Email: aysencanan95@gmail.com
      • Contact: Ayşen Canan Pakeloğlu, Physiotherapist

Participation Criteria

Eligibility Criteria

• Ages Eligible for Study: Adult
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Description

Inclusion Criteria:

• Being between the ages of 18 and 55,
• Scoring 15/50 or less on the Neck Disability Index,
• Having a history of chronic neck pain for at least 3 months,
• Having a pain level of 5/10 or more,
• Showing signs of cervical movement control dysfunction,
• Having cervical muscle tenderness during physical examination.

Exclusion Criteria:

• Being diagnosed with a vascular disease,
• Being diagnosed with a vestibular disease,
• Being diagnosed with hypertension,
• Being diagnosed with fibromyalgia or rheumatoid arthritis,
• Having had spine surgery in the last 12 months,
• Having received an exercise program or standard physiotherapy program involving the cervical region in the last 12 months,
• Having congenital or acquired kyphosis, scoliosis, etc. having postural deformity,
• Having specific neck pain such as cancer,
• Having fractures, instability, inflammatory diseases, history of neck trauma, infections, neurological deficit, having spinal diseases such as radiculopathy, spondylosis.

Study Plan

How is the study designed?

Design Details

• Primary Purpose: Treatment
• Allocation: Randomized
• Interventional Model: Parallel Assignment
• Masking: Double

Number of Arms

4

Arms and Interventions

Participant Group / Arm	Intervention / Treatment
Active Comparator: Conventional Treatment; Conventional treatment will include electrotherapy agents (TENS, ultrasound and hotpack) and chin tuck posture exercises.	Other: Conventional Treatment Group; TENS will be applied with a TENS device at an intensity of 10-30 mA and a frequency of 80 Hz for 20 minutes. A pair of surface electrodes will be placed on the painful area of the neck. The intensity of TENS will be adjusted according to the patient's sensory thresholds so that the patient is not disturbed by a numb feeling. After TENS, continuous ultrasound will be applied to the cervical region to produce thermal effects. The intensity will be 1.5 W/cm² and the duration will be 5 minutes. Hotpack will be applied to the trapezius muscle for 10 minutes. Chin tuck exercise will be applied to the cervical region.Treatments will be performed 3 days a week for 8 weeks.
Active Comparator: Craniocervical Flexion Exercise Training; Patients will receive exercise in addition to conventional treatment. The exercises will be performed with an air-filled pressure stabilizer placed in the sub-occipital region.	Other: Conventional Treatment Group; TENS will be applied with a TENS device at an intensity of 10-30 mA and a frequency of 80 Hz for 20 minutes. A pair of surface electrodes will be placed on the painful area of the neck. The intensity of TENS will be adjusted according to the patient's sensory thresholds so that the patient is not disturbed by a numb feeling. After TENS, continuous ultrasound will be applied to the cervical region to produce thermal effects. The intensity will be 1.5 W/cm² and the duration will be 5 minutes. Hotpack will be applied to the trapezius muscle for 10 minutes. Chin tuck exercise will be applied to the cervical region.Treatments will be performed 3 days a week for 8 weeks.; Other: Craniocervical Flexion Exercise Group; The patient will first be taught to contract the deep cervical flexors. Patients will be placed in a supine position (without a pillow) to ensure a neutral neck position. Patients will be asked to perform slow, controlled head and upper cervical flexion by bringing the chin closer to the chest ("yes" movement). The stabilizer will be inflated to 20 mmHg. Gradual training will be given to increase the pressure value by 2 mmHg between 20 and 30 mmHg. Each pressure value (22, 24, 26, 28 mmHg) will be held for 10 seconds and repeated 10 times. The exercise will be performed with 10 repetitions, 10 seconds of contraction and 5 seconds of relaxation. Exercise training will begin with 20 mmHg and once the patient can hold it for 10 seconds with 10 repetitions, the next level on the pressure stabilizer will be moved on.Treatments will be performed 3 days a week for 8 weeks.
Active Comparator: Dynamic Isometric Exercise Training; Patients will receive exercise in addition to conventional treatment. The exercises will be performed by the patient with an elastic band.	Other: Conventional Treatment Group; TENS will be applied with a TENS device at an intensity of 10-30 mA and a frequency of 80 Hz for 20 minutes. A pair of surface electrodes will be placed on the painful area of the neck. The intensity of TENS will be adjusted according to the patient's sensory thresholds so that the patient is not disturbed by a numb feeling. After TENS, continuous ultrasound will be applied to the cervical region to produce thermal effects. The intensity will be 1.5 W/cm² and the duration will be 5 minutes. Hotpack will be applied to the trapezius muscle for 10 minutes. Chin tuck exercise will be applied to the cervical region.Treatments will be performed 3 days a week for 8 weeks.; Other: Dynamic Isometric Exercise Group; The exercises will be performed by the patient with an elastic band. The progression of the exercises will be performed using different colors of Thera-bands with different resistances. It will start with the red Thera-band with the lowest resistance and then move on to the green and then blue Thera-bands with increasing resistance. Cervical isometric exercises will be performed with elastic resistance bands, maintaining the chin tuck position, forward, backward, crosswise, right and left. There will be 10 repetitions for 10 seconds for each. Progression in Therabands will be according to the patient. When the patient does 10 repetitions for 10 seconds, the next Theraband will be used.Treatments will be performed 3 days a week for 8 weeks.
Active Comparator: Static Isometric Exercise Training; Patients will receive exercise in addition to conventional treatment. The patient will perform isometric exercises with maximal effort against neck flexion, extension, lateral flexion and rotation with his/her hand in a sitting position.	Other: Conventional Treatment Group; TENS will be applied with a TENS device at an intensity of 10-30 mA and a frequency of 80 Hz for 20 minutes. A pair of surface electrodes will be placed on the painful area of the neck. The intensity of TENS will be adjusted according to the patient's sensory thresholds so that the patient is not disturbed by a numb feeling. After TENS, continuous ultrasound will be applied to the cervical region to produce thermal effects. The intensity will be 1.5 W/cm² and the duration will be 5 minutes. Hotpack will be applied to the trapezius muscle for 10 minutes. Chin tuck exercise will be applied to the cervical region.Treatments will be performed 3 days a week for 8 weeks.; Other: Static Isometric Exercise Group; The patient will perform isometric exercises with maximal effort against neck flexion, extension, lateral flexion and rotation with his/her hand in a sitting position. Each exercise will be performed for 10 seconds, with 15-second breaks in between, for 10 repetitions. Each patient will start with submaximal resistance to help them adapt to isometric exercises, and then progress will be checked until the patient reaches the maximum resistance that can be tolerated by each session. It will consist of cervical flexion, cervical extension, right lateral flexion, left lateral flexion, right rotation, left rotation exercises. Progress in the exercises will be according to the Rating of Perceived Exertion Borg (RPE) Scale according to the weeks.Treatments will be performed 3 days a week for 8 weeks.

What is the study measuring?

Primary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure	Measure Description	Time Frame
Pain Assesment	The assessment will be made with Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and algometer. VAS is considered both valid and reliable in measuring the pain intensity of patients. Each participant will be asked to indicate the intensity of pain they have experienced in the previous 24 hours. This will be done by marking on a 10 cm line where "0" is "No Pain" and "10" is "Maximum Pain".	8 week
Pain Assesment	An algometer with a 1 cm2 rounded surface area will be used for objective pain assessment. Measurements will be made on the spinous processes of C2 and c5 and the trapezius muscle. The assessor will gradually increase the pressure until pain or discomfort occurs and the patient says "yes". The average of the three measurements will be taken. A 30-second rest period will be given between each measurement.	8 week
Disability Assesment	Neck Disability Index, designed to assess how neck pain affects daily living activities, will be used. The questionnaire includes 10 items that measure disability secondary to neck pain. Scores range from 0-50 and are interpreted as follows: 0-4 represents no disability,; 5-14 represents mild disability,; 15-24 represents moderate disability,; 25-33 represents severe disability,; 34 and above represents complete disability.	8 week

Secondary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure	Measure Description	Time Frame
Cervical Joint Range of Motion Assessment	Goniometer will be used for active ROM (flexion, extension, left/right rotation, left/right lateral flexion) measurements. Maximum ROM will be measured in degrees for each test. Participants will be asked to sit against the back of the chair, look forward, and position their arms in a relaxed manner.	8 week
Cervical Postur Assesment	Tragus Wall Distance Measurement will be performed with 2-3 practical trials to ensure that the participant has taken the correct posture. After the posture is appropriate, the tragus wall distance will be measured with a millimeter ruler while the participants stand naturally and perform cervical retraction	8 week
Cervical Postur Assesment	The craniovertebral angle will be measured for forward head posture in the sagittal plane. The craniovertebral angle will be measured with the photograph method. The camera is fixed 1.5 meters away on a flat surface aligned with the humeral head of the participants. The participants are asked to perform head flexion-extension movements to find the neutral head position and the participants are told to stay in the most appropriate position. A cursor is placed on the c7 spinous process and tragus in the photograph. The participants' photographs are taken 3 times. Craniovertebral angle is measured with the photographs taken and noted in degrees. The angles are averaged. Image processing will be done with Image J software	8 week
Cervical Strength Assessment	Hand Held dynamometer will be used for strength assessment. It will include 3 isometric contractions held for 3 seconds for flexion, extension, lateral flexion and rotation movements. The value greater than the maximal contractions will be recorded.	8 week
Cervical Endurance Assessment	In the Craniocervical Flexion Test, participants will be in a supine position and the compressed air unit will be placed behind the cervical spine, just below the occiput. It will be inflated to 20 mmHg initially and participants will be instructed to perform the craniocervical flexion movement. Thus, the pressure will increase to 22 mmHg and they will be asked to maintain this position for 10 seconds. Then, a 30-second rest period will be given and the entire procedure will be repeated for 24, 26, 28 and 30 mmHg. The final reading will be taken when the participant cannot hold the specific pressure for 10 seconds. Before the test, participants will be given enough time to practice.	8 week
Cervical Endurance Assesment	Cervical Flexion Endurance Test: Participants will be asked to lie in a crook-lying position. The physiotherapist will place their hand under the patient's head. They will be asked to lift their head approximately 2.5 cm off the bed and maintain this position for as long as possible. The test will end when the patient feels any pain or fatigue or when their head touches the therapist's hand. Endurance time was measured in seconds. The test will be performed twice with 3 minutes of rest between repetitions.	8 week
Cervical Endurance Assessment	Cervical Extensor Endurance Test: For the test, patients will be asked to lie in a prone position with their head and upper body positioned on the edge of the bed and their arms next to their body. A 2 kg sandbag will be placed on the patient's cervical region. They will then be asked to lift their head to a neutral position and maintain this position. The test will end when the patient feels any pain or fatigue or when there is a 5° deterioration in head position (measured with an inclinometer). The test will be repeated twice with a 3-minute rest interval and the longest holding time in seconds will be recorded as the test result.	8 week
Neck Awareness Assesment	It will be evaluated with the Fremantle Neck Awareness Questionnaire. It is a simple Likert-type questionnaire (0=Never/Never feel like this, 1= Rarely feel like this, 2= Sometimes or some of the time feel like this, 3= Often feel like this, 4= Always or most of the time feel like this) that evaluates the individual's altered perception. The questionnaire asks individuals 9 questions such as how they perceive their neck in relation to their body.	8 week

Collaborators and Investigators

• Sponsor: Muğla Sıtkı Koçman University

Study record dates

Study Major Dates

• Study Start (Actual): June 24, 2024
• Primary Completion (Estimated): January 1, 2025
• Study Completion (Estimated): February 1, 2025

Study Registration Dates

• First Submitted: November 18, 2024
• First Submitted That Met QC Criteria: November 18, 2024
• First Posted (Estimated): November 20, 2024

Study Record Updates

• Last Update Posted (Estimated): November 20, 2024
• Last Update Submitted That Met QC Criteria: November 18, 2024
• Last Verified: June 1, 2024

More Information

Terms related to this study

• Keywords: exercise; neck pain; chronic
• Additional Relevant MeSH Terms: Pain; Neurologic Manifestations; Neck Pain
• Other Study ID Numbers: MSKU-FTR-ACP-01

Plan for Individual participant data (IPD)

• Plan to Share Individual Participant Data (IPD)?: NO

Drug and device information, study documents

• Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated drug product: No
• Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated device product: No
• product manufactured in and exported from the U.S.: No