The Effects of Different Storage Conditions on Removable Retainers

August 26, 2023 updated by: Dr Wan Nurazreena Wan Hassan, University of Malaya

A Randomised Crossover Clinical Trial to Compare the Effects of Different Storage Conditions on Removable Retainers

Orthodontic removable retainers are appliances that hold the position of the upper and lower teeth after fixed braces treatment and they can be removed from a patient's mouth. Basically, there are 2 types of removable retainers; Hawley retainer and vacuum-formed retainer.

Hawley retainer is made of an acrylic resin plate that covers the palate for the upper jaw and the back of the arch facing the tongue for the lower jaw. It has thin stainless-steel wires incorporated to fit the first molars and the six front teeth as retention.

Vacuum-formed retainer (VFR) is a clear or transparent plastic retainer. It covers the teeth completely and a small part of the gum.

The investigators' interest is to determine whether the storage conditions will affect the amount of bacteria, appearance and strength of removable retainers. Primarily, the amount of bacteria that sticks to the retainers may cause overall dental and oral health effects such as mouth odour, dental caries and gum problems. The investigators would also like to assess the oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL) of participants after storing retainers in different storage conditions by answering a questionnaire.

Study Overview

Status

Recruiting

Conditions

Intervention / Treatment

Detailed Description

RATIONALE OF THE STUDY

A non-bias clinical study is required to facilitate the best recommendation to care for the orthodontic retainers. This may prevent the risk of further harms to the oral condition and increase the longevity of the retainers. In turn, this would improve the OHRQoL of orthodontic patients and potentially save the cost of retainer replacements. Therefore, the findings may help to provide evidence-based guidelines for the storage method of removable retainers.

Primary Objective

  1. To compare the microbial colony counts of removable retainers in wet and dry storage conditions.

    Secondary Objectives

  2. To compare the surface roughness of removable retainer materials in wet and dry storage conditions.
  3. To compare the colour stability of removable retainer materials in wet and dry storage conditions.
  4. To compare the compressive strength of removable retainer materials in wet and dry storage conditions.
  5. To evaluate OHRQoL of participants storing their removable retainers in dry and wet conditions.

SAMPLE SIZE CALCULATION

Sample size calculation was done using G* Power 3.1. The total sample size is 18, for an alpha error equivalent to 0.05, a study power equivalent to 80%, a two-sided test type, and an effect size of 1.316 (Farhadian et al., 2016). Considering a potential dropout of 30%, therefore 24 participants will be recruited.

METHODOLOGY

Participants who fit the inclusion and exclusion criteria will be invited to enrol at the Orthodontic Postgraduate Clinic, Faculty of Dentistry, Universiti Malaya. Once the participants consent to take part in this study, an explanation will be given in detail of the procedure of the research with the aid of the flowchart diagram. The participants will also be given a participant information sheet. An appointment for the removal of fixed braces will be scheduled.

All participants will be required to draw lots from the sealed envelope which has been randomised by the consultant orthodontist to know their first retainer storage condition. The investigator will have to check the group allocation with the consultant orthodontist.

On the first appointment day, the removal of braces will be done according to the standard protocol. Then, four sets of impressions will be taken to construct the models and retainers. The participants will be issued with their regular upper and lower retainers, a new toothbrush and a retainer box. The participants will be instructed to store their retainers in a dry retainer box or in a glass of clean water the entire time when not in use. Other home care instructions include: 1) wear the retainers part-time (8-12 hours daily), 2) clean the retainers with a soft-bristled toothbrush and rinse thoroughly, and 3) no additional cleaning solutions and tablets are allowed. The participants will need to answer a self-administered questionnaire 1 week later to assess their personal judgment on the removable retainers.

The participants will be called 3 months later for review (T1). During this visit, the standard retainers will be taken by the investigator for analysis. The interventional retainers will be issued to the participants with an instruction to exchange the storage method from dry to wet conditions and from wet to dry conditions. The same home care instructions will be advised. The participants will receive a new toothbrush to clean their appliance and a new retainer box to keep their retainers. The participants will need to answer a questionnaire sheet again.

The participants will be called 6 months later for review (T2). The first interventional retainers will be taken by the investigator for the final analysis. The second interventional retainers will be issued to the participants and they will be instructed to continue caring for their retainers. All participants will be required to answer a questionnaire sheet for the final time.

Three different sets of the newly constructed Hawley and vacuum-formed retainers will be tested for microbial analysis, physical and mechanical properties as baseline characteristics for comparisons.

STATISTICAL ANALYSIS

Results obtained will be computed using SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 26.0. Statistical significance will be set at p < 0.05.

The manipulating variables are the types of storage conditions, which are dry and wet with α = 5% = 0.05 and confidence interval (CI) of 95%. Test of normality will be done using the Shapiro-Wilk test for each of the dependent variables (outcomes).

i. Mann-Whitney U-Test will be applied to compare the dependent variables of the two groups (Hawley retainers and VFRs) at baseline, T1 and T2.

ii. Wilcoxon Signed Rank test will be used to compare the storage conditions of the two groups (Hawley retainers and VFRs) at baseline, T1 and T2.

iii. Kruskal Wallis will be carried out to investigate the interaction between the two samples and the storage conditions.

iv. If the data is normally distributed, then the equivalent parametric analyses (paired t-test and independent t-test) will be performed.

Study Type

Interventional

Enrollment (Estimated)

24

Phase

  • Not Applicable

Contacts and Locations

This section provides the contact details for those conducting the study, and information on where this study is being conducted.

Study Contact

Study Contact Backup

Study Locations

  • Malaysia
    • Wilayah Persekutuan
      • Kuala Lumpur, Wilayah Persekutuan, Malaysia, 50603
        • Recruiting
        • Orthodontic Postgraduate Clinic, Faculty of Dentistry
        • Contact:
        • Contact:

Participation Criteria

Researchers look for people who fit a certain description, called eligibility criteria. Some examples of these criteria are a person's general health condition or prior treatments.

Eligibility Criteria

Ages Eligible for Study

  • Adult
  • Older Adult

Accepts Healthy Volunteers

Yes

Description

Inclusion Criteria:

  • Patients aged 18 years and above
  • Fixed appliance treatment on both the upper and lower arches
  • Ready for debond
  • Planned for either Hawley retainers or VFRs for retention
  • Fit and healthy patients without systemic disease
  • Non-smoking patients

Exclusion Criteria:

  • Sectional fixed appliance treatment or fixed appliance treatment on single arch only
  • Planned for double retention with bonded retainers
  • Systemic disease that may affect salivary flow
  • Smoking patients

Study Plan

This section provides details of the study plan, including how the study is designed and what the study is measuring.

How is the study designed?

Design Details

  • Primary Purpose: Screening
  • Allocation: Randomized
  • Interventional Model: Crossover Assignment
  • Masking: Single

Arms and Interventions

Participant Group / Arm
Intervention / Treatment
Experimental: Hawley retainers in dry storage condition
Acrylic retainers to be stored in a dry retainer box the entire time when not in use.
Device: Hawley retainers in dry storage condition
Three months later, an exchange of storage methods from dry to wet conditions will take place.
Other Names:
  • Acrylic retainers
Experimental: Hawley retainers in wet storage condition
Acrylic retainers to be stored in a glass of clean tap water the entire time when not in use.
Device: Hawley retainers in wet storage condition
Three months later, an exchange of storage methods from wet to dry conditions will take place.
Other Names:
  • Acrylic retainers
Experimental: Vacuum-formed retainers in dry storage condition
Thermoplastic retainers to be stored in a dry retainer box the entire time when not in use.
Device: VFRs in dry storage condition
Three months later, an exchange of storage methods from dry to wet conditions will take place.
Other Names:
  • Thermoplastic clear retainers
Experimental: Vacuum-formed retainers in wet storage condition
Thermoplastic retainers to be stored in a glass of clean tap water the entire time when not in use.
Device: VFRs in wet storage condition
Three months later, an exchange of storage methods from wet to dry conditions will take place.
Other Names:
  • Thermoplastic clear retainers
Active Comparator: Baseline characteristics
Newly constructed Hawley retainers and VFRs will be labeled as baseline samples.
Device: Baseline characteristics
Hawley retainers and VFRs that are newly constructed will be used as baseline samples. The samples will be taken for microbial, physical and mechanical tests.

What is the study measuring?

Primary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure
Measure Description
Time Frame
Microbial colony counts of removable retainers in wet and dry storage conditions
Time Frame: 6 months
Removable retainers will be sonicated and vortexed to dislodge bacteria. Serial dilution will be done and bacterial suspension will be pipetted on a BHI agar petri dish. Total bacterial count in CFU/ml will be counted at baseline, T1 and T2.
6 months

Secondary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure
Measure Description
Time Frame
Surface roughness of removable retainers in wet and dry storage conditions
Time Frame: 6 months
Surface roughness will be measured with a surface roughness profilometer (Mitutoyo, Japan). A stylus will make a contact on a surface of the removable retainer and give a measurement in Ra (average surface roughness) parameter. Reading will be taken at baseline, T1 and T2.
6 months
Colour stability of removable retainers in wet and dry storage conditions
Time Frame: 6 months
The colour changes of the removable retainers will be measured with a colour spectrophotometer (Konica Minolta, Japan) at baseline, T1 and T2.
6 months
Compressive strength of removable retainers in wet and dry storage conditions
Time Frame: 6 months
Compressive strength will be done using a universal testing machine (AG-X Series, Shimadzu, Japan). 5 kN compressive load with a loading rate of 1.0 mm/min will be applied at baseline, T1 and T2.
6 months
OHRQoL of participants storing their removable retainers in dry and wet conditions
Time Frame: 6 months

The questionnaire is modified following a similar study of a randomised crossover clinical study comparing vacuum-formed thermoplastic retainers constructed on a conventional stone models and on 3D reconstructed study model.

The OHRQoL is measured by using a modified 14-item Malaysian version of the Oral Health Impact Profile [OHIP-14(M)].

The content focuses on the impact of oral health on quality of life through seven domains: 1) functional limitation, 2) physical pain, 3) psychological discomfort, 4) physical disability, 5) psychological disability, 6) social disability, and 7) handicap. Likert scale is used to measure the score for the responses; 0 = never, 1 = hardly ever, 2 = occasionally, 3 = fairly often, 4 = very often.
6 months

Collaborators and Investigators

This is where you will find people and organizations involved with this study.

Sponsor

University of Malaya

Publications and helpful links

The person responsible for entering information about the study voluntarily provides these publications. These may be about anything related to the study.

General Publications

Study record dates

These dates track the progress of study record and summary results submissions to ClinicalTrials.gov. Study records and reported results are reviewed by the National Library of Medicine (NLM) to make sure they meet specific quality control standards before being posted on the public website.

Study Major Dates

Study Start (Actual)

May 10, 2023

Primary Completion (Estimated)

March 1, 2024

Study Completion (Estimated)

September 1, 2024

Study Registration Dates

First Submitted

April 17, 2023

First Submitted That Met QC Criteria

May 8, 2023

First Posted (Actual)

May 11, 2023

Study Record Updates

Last Update Posted (Actual)

August 30, 2023

Last Update Submitted That Met QC Criteria

August 26, 2023

Last Verified

August 1, 2023

More Information

Terms related to this study

Keywords

Additional Relevant MeSH Terms

Other Study ID Numbers

  • S2042680

Plan for Individual participant data (IPD)

Plan to Share Individual Participant Data (IPD)?

NO

Drug and device information, study documents

Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated drug product

No

Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated device product

No

This information was retrieved directly from the website clinicaltrials.gov without any changes. If you have any requests to change, remove or update your study details, please contact register@clinicaltrials.gov. As soon as a change is implemented on clinicaltrials.gov, this will be updated automatically on our website as well.

Clinical Trials on Orthodontic Appliance Complication

Search Similar Trials

Sponsors and Collaborators

Medical Conditions

Drug Interventions

CROs by country

CROs in Angola

Conditions

Rare Diseases

Drug Interventions

Dietary Supplements

Sponsor/Collaborators

Locations

Subscribe