A Comparison of the Analgesic Efficacies of Ultrasound and Shock Wave Therapy in the Patients With Calcaneal Spur

Heel spur is a troublesome disorder. Its formation is accompanied by pain in the area of heel and it makes walking limited or even impossible.

The aim of the study is to analyze analgesic efficacy of ultrasound and shock wave therapy in patients with heel spur.

The study included 52 patients of both sexes, aged 38-86 (average 57.39) with plantar heel spur confirmed radiographically. The patients were randomly divided into two groups;in Group 1 the patients underwent ultrasound procedure (10 treatments)and in Group 2 - radial shock wave procedure(6 treatments). The researchers assessed pain three times (prior to the therapy, after the first and then the second week of treatment). In order to do this they used a modified form of the Laitinen pain indicators questionnaire (results expressed in points) and VAS - visual analogue scale (results given in milimeters). The results were statistically analyzed. In the studied periods of time a decrease in pain was observed (both in the Laitinen questionnaire and in the VAS scale). The most rapid change was noted in both the groups after the first week of treatment. Ultrasound and shock wave therapies show a comparably significant analgesic efficacy in patients with heel spur. Shock wave therapy has an advantage over ultrasound therapy. A smaller number of procedures is required to obtain comparable results, which makes the therapy less expensive. No side effects were observed during and after the treatment.

Study Overview

• Status: Completed
• Conditions: Heel Spur

Detailed Description

The study was conducted on a group of 52 patients of both sexes, aged 38-86 years (mean 57.39; SD-11.5) with a plantar calcaneal spur confirmed by X-ray images. Patients were treated in the Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Day Unit of the University Hospital im. WAM - Central Veterans Hospital in Lodz and Municipal Health Clinic of Andrespol. In order to compare the effectiveness of the two forms of physiotherapy, ultrasound and radial shock wave therapy, the patients were randomly assigned (using a simple randomization) into two groups:

• Group 1 - ultrasound therapy group: 22 patients aged 38-86 years (mean 58.64; SD-12.99),
• Group 2 - radial shock wave group: 30 patients aged 40-71 years (mean 56.13; SD-10.02).

Ultrasound (US) was performed with a BTL 5840 S device, using labile technique, targeting the calcaneal tumor and attachment of the plantar aponeurosis (pain points); the power setting was 1,5 W/cm2, 80% fill factor, at a frequency of 1 MHz (head 4cm2). The duration of a single treatment was four minutes, and the coupling substance used was paraffin oil. Treatment sessions were performed daily Monday through Friday for a period of two weeks in a series of 10 treatments.

The shock wave therapy (SWT) was performed on the affected area using a BTL-5000 SWT device connected to a 15 mm diameter applicator according to the producer's recommendations; during therapy, 2000 strokes were applied with a frequency of 10 Hz and a capacity of 2.5 bar. Therapy took place for two weeks in a series of 6 treatments with a two-day interval between treatments.

In addition, all patients underwent kinesitherapy - exercises to strengthen the muscles that bending plantar and supinated foot to improve the mobility of the feet and to maintain the normal longitudinal arch of the foot. SPR orthopedic inserts with a pit on the painful area was used to support the longitudinal foot arch and relieve the medial ridge of the calcaneal tumor.

In all patients, pain intensity was assessed three times: before therapy, and after the first and second week of treatment. A modified form of the Laitinen indicators of pain question-shem was used [12]. On the basis of their subjective feelings, patients evaluated pain intensity, frequency of occurrence, use of analgesics, and the impact of pain on their physical activity. In addition, pain intensity was also assessed on the Huskisson visual - analogue scale (VAS) [13]; patients marked a point on a 100 mm line which corresponded to the current pain sensations - the results being given in millimeters.

The results were analyzed by Student's t-test for dependent and independent tests, with a significance level of p <0.05. The results are presented as arithmetic mean and standard deviation.

• Study Type: Observational
• Enrollment (Actual): 3

Participation Criteria

Eligibility Criteria

• Ages Eligible for Study: 38 years to 86 years (Adult, Older Adult)
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No
• Genders Eligible for Study: All

• Sampling Method: Probability Sample

Study Population

The study was conducted on a group of 52 patients of both sexes, aged 38-86 years (mean 57.39; SD-11.5) with a plantar calcaneal spur confirmed by X-ray images. Patients were treated in the Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Day Unit of the University Hospital im. WAM - Central Veterans Hospital in Lodz and Municipal Health Clinic of Andrespol. In order to compare the effectiveness of the two forms of physiotherapy, ultrasound and radial shock wave therapy, the patients were randomly assigned (using a simple randomization) into two groups:

• Group 1 - ultrasound therapy group: 22 patients aged 38-86 years (mean 58.64; SD-12.99),
• Group 2 - radial shock wave group: 30 patients aged 40-71 years (mean 56.13; SD-10.02).

Description

Inclusion Criteria:

• plantar calcaneal spur confirmed by X-ray images

Exclusion Criteria:

• contraindications for physical therapy

Study Plan

How is the study designed?

Design Details

• Observational Models: Case-Control
• Time Perspectives: Retrospective

What is the study measuring?

Primary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure	Time Frame
A Comparison of the Analgesic Efficacies of Ultrasound and Shock Wave Therapy in the Patients With Calcaneal Spur	two weeks in a series of 10 ultrasound treatments and 6 radial shock wave treatments

Collaborators and Investigators

• Sponsor: Medical University of Lodz
• Investigators: Principal Investigator: Jolanta Krukowska, PhD, Medical University of Lodz

Study record dates

Study Major Dates

• Study Start: January 1, 2010
• Primary Completion (Actual): January 1, 2011
• Study Completion (Actual): June 1, 2011

Study Registration Dates

• First Submitted: December 16, 2011
• First Submitted That Met QC Criteria: January 13, 2012
• First Posted (Estimate): January 16, 2012

Study Record Updates

• Last Update Posted (Estimate): January 16, 2012
• Last Update Submitted That Met QC Criteria: January 13, 2012
• Last Verified: January 1, 2012

More Information

Terms related to this study

• Keywords: ultrasound therapy; shock wave therapy; calcaneal spur
• Additional Relevant MeSH Terms: Foot Diseases; Musculoskeletal Diseases; Bone Diseases; Exostoses; Hyperostosis; Heel Spur
• Other Study ID Numbers: JKrukowska01