3D-Printed Vs Thermoformed Retainers: Comparison of Post-Treatment Stability, Changes in Mechanical Properties and Patients' OHRQoL

September 5, 2023 updated by: DR BOO HUI SHAN, University of Malaya

Post-Treatment Stability, Changes in Mechanical Properties and Patients' OHRQoL Of Direct 3D-Printed Retainers Versus Thermoformed Retainers: An Open-label Randomized Controlled Trial

Following completion of orthodontic treatment, prolonged retention with either part-time or full-time wear of retainers is crucial in preventing relapse. Clear thermoformed retainers (TFR) are easy to fabricate and popular among orthodontic patients. With the advent of digital orthodontics and the development of biocompatible photopolymerizable resin, it is now possible to fabricate direct 3D-printed retainers.

The aim of this study is to determine and compare the post-treatment stability of dentition, changes in thickness and mechanical properties of the retainers, and oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL) of patients wearing direct 3D-printed retainers and conventional thermoformed retainers over a retention period of 6 months.

Study Overview

Status

Recruiting

Conditions

Intervention / Treatment

Detailed Description

Primary Objective:

1. To determine and compare the post-treatment stability for direct 3D printed retainers (3DPR) and conventional TFR (TFR) at baseline (T0), 3 months (T1) and 6 months (T2).

Secondary Objectives:

  1. To determine and compare the thickness and mechanical properties for 3DPR and TFR after 6 months of usage.
  2. To determine and compare the OHRQoL of patients wearing 3DPR and TFR at T0, T1 and T2.

Sample size calculation:

Sample size calculation is based on the study done by Kumar & Bansal (2011) which compared the effectiveness of two different removable retainers on stability. With an effect size of 1.127, α = 0.05, and power = 0.80. Using G*Power version 3.1.9.7 software, the total number of samples is n = 22 (11 subject per group). This number is increased by 30% to account for the dropout rate to produce the final sample size, n = 30 (15 subjects per group).

Methodology:

Subjects who have completed their orthodontic treatment (fulfil the inclusion and exclusion criteria) and are ready for debond, will be invited to participate in the research and consecutively recruited, between April 2023 until September 2023, in the Postgraduate Orthodontic Clinic, Dental Specialists and Research Tower, Faculty of Dentistry, Universiti Malaya, Malaysia. Patient information sheets and consent forms will be issued to the subjects that fulfil the criteria. Only consented respondents will be recruited.

All 30 subjects will be randomly allocated (simple randomization with 1:1 allocation) to either the TFR group or the 3DPR group by using number generated list provided by www.random.org . The randomization will be performed by the main supervisor, who is not involve in the treatment, data collection and data analysis of the research. The operator will be concealed from the group allocation. The allocation will be revealed to the operator on the day of debond appointment with a opaque white envelope.

All the subjects will undergo the same standard debond process. and receive a post debond thermoformed retainers within 24 hours which they are required to part-time for every night (8-12 hours).

The subjects will be reviewed after 1 week (T0) for scanning of teeth with Trios 3 intraoral scanner. The interventional retainers (TFR or 3DPR) will be issued after 2 weeks. The subjects are instructed to wear the retainers part-time (8-12 hours) for every nights. A pamphlet that contains detailed information on the care of retainers will also be provided to every subject. All the subjects will be reviewed after 3 months (T1) and at 6 months (T2) after wearing the interventional retainers.

The primary outcome is to assess the post-treatment stability after part time wear of the retainers for a period of 6 months. The subject's upper and lower dentition will be scanned by using intraoral scanner at T0, T1, and T2. The measurements will be performed digitally using 3Shape orthodontic analyzer software. Overjet, overbite, intermolar width, and little irregularity index will be measured.

OHIP-14 questionnaire will be given to the participants to answer during T0, T1 and T2. All the retainers will be retrieved at T2 to undergo mechanical test.

Statistical Analysis:

The data collected will be entered into SPSS software (version 26.0). i. Chi-square tests will be used to compare baseline characteristics between the 2 groups.

ii. Repeated measures ANOVA or paired t-test will be used to determine the mean differences in post treatment stability, thickness of retainers, mechanical properties of retainers and OHIP-14 scores at different time intervals. The p-value will be set to less than 0.05.

iii. Two samples independent t test will be used to compare the post-treatment stability, changes in thickness, mechanical properties, and OHIP-14 scores between TFR and 3DPR group. The p-value will be set to less than 0.05.

iv. Shapiro-Wilk tests will be referred, and non-parametric tests will be performed for skewed data.

Data will be analyzed following the intention-to-treat analysis.

Study Type

Interventional

Enrollment (Estimated)

30

Phase

  • Not Applicable

Contacts and Locations

This section provides the contact details for those conducting the study, and information on where this study is being conducted.

Study Contact

Study Contact Backup

  • Name: Associate Professor Dr. Saritha Sivarajan
  • Phone Number: 4562 +6037967 4802
  • Email: saritha@um.edu.my

Study Locations

  • Malaysia
    • Wilayah Persekutuan
      • Kuala Lumpur, Wilayah Persekutuan, Malaysia, 50603
        • Recruiting
        • Orthodontic Postgraduate Clinic, Faculty of Dentistry, Universiti Malaya.
        • Contact:
        • Contact:
          • Associate Professor Dr. Saritha Sivarajan
          • Phone Number: 4562 +60379674802
          • Email: saritha@um.edu.my

Participation Criteria

Researchers look for people who fit a certain description, called eligibility criteria. Some examples of these criteria are a person's general health condition or prior treatments.

Eligibility Criteria

Ages Eligible for Study

  • Adult
  • Older Adult

Accepts Healthy Volunteers

Yes

Description

Inclusion Criteria:

  • Fixed appliance treatment in both arches and indicated for VFR in the retention phase as part of their original treatment plan.
  • No intention to relocate within the study period; able to attend the three-monthly review appointments for half a year.

Exclusion Criteria:

  • Single-arch or sectional fixed appliances.
  • Space dentition.
  • Hypodontia requiring tooth replacement on the retainer as a temporary measure.
  • Previous treatment with maxillary expansion.
  • Indicated for fixed retainer or double retention regime (such as VFRs fitted over fixed retainers).
  • Premature debond from the original fixed appliances course.
  • Cleft lip and/or palate; or orthognathic cases.
  • Learning difficulties and inability to read written instructions/ questionnaire in English or Malay

Study Plan

This section provides details of the study plan, including how the study is designed and what the study is measuring.

How is the study designed?

Design Details

  • Primary Purpose: Screening
  • Allocation: Randomized
  • Interventional Model: Parallel Assignment
  • Masking: Single

Arms and Interventions

Participant Group / Arm
Intervention / Treatment
Experimental: Thermoformed retainers (TFR)
Thermoformed retainers are constructed from an Erkodur blank (ERKODENT® Erich Kopp GmbH, Pfalzgrafenweiler, Germany) with 1.0 mm in thickness, following the manufacturer's instructions.
Device: Thermoformed retainers
conventional thermoformed retainers fabricated on stone models.
Experimental: Direct 3-D printed retainers (3DPR)
Private dental laboratories directly print the retainers using a NextDent 3D printer and NextDent ortho Flex resin. Thickness of 0.80mm
Device: 3D-printed retainers
3D-printed retainers fabricated directly by DLP printer.

What is the study measuring?

Primary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure
Measure Description
Time Frame
Post-treatment stability
Time Frame: 6 months
The subject's upper and lower dentition will be scanned by using intraoral scanner at T0, T1, and T2. The measurements will be performed digitally using 3Shape orthodontic Analyzer software (3Shape A/S, Copenhagen, Denmark). Measurements: Overjet (mm), Overbite (mm), Intermolar width (mm), and little irregularity index (mm). All the measurements are in millimetres.
6 months

Secondary Outcome Measures

Outcome Measure
Measure Description
Time Frame
Changes in thickness of retainers
Time Frame: 6 months
Measurements of changes in thickness (mm) will be performed by the principal investigator by using an electronic digital thickness gauge with a resolution of 0.01 mm and accuracy of ±0.02 mm, which will be calibrated before each use.
6 months
Changes in hardness of retainers
Time Frame: 6 months
The extra sets of retainers (5 sets from each group) at T0 and the retrieved retainers (5 sets from each group) at T2 of each group will be tested. The hardness that will be determined is Vickers hardness in Megapascal (MPa). A universal hardness testing machine (DUH-211S, Shimadzu, Kyoto Japan) will be used to determine the hardness.
6 months
Oral Health Impact Profile -14 (OHIP-14)
Time Frame: 6 months
This research will use the validated Modified short version of the OHIP-14 for Malaysian adults with questions that are relevant to subjects wearing removable retainers. Responses to each item will be scored on a five-point Likert scale measuring from never (score 0) to very often (score 4). The OHIP-14 questionnaire will be given to the participants to answer during T0, T1 and T2.
6 months

Collaborators and Investigators

This is where you will find people and organizations involved with this study.

Sponsor

University of Malaya

Investigators

  • Study Director: Associate Professor Dr. Saritha Sivarajan, Faculty of Dentistry, Universiti Malaya

Publications and helpful links

The person responsible for entering information about the study voluntarily provides these publications. These may be about anything related to the study.

General Publications

Study record dates

These dates track the progress of study record and summary results submissions to ClinicalTrials.gov. Study records and reported results are reviewed by the National Library of Medicine (NLM) to make sure they meet specific quality control standards before being posted on the public website.

Study Major Dates

Study Start (Actual)

March 28, 2023

Primary Completion (Estimated)

May 1, 2024

Study Completion (Estimated)

October 1, 2024

Study Registration Dates

First Submitted

July 17, 2023

First Submitted That Met QC Criteria

July 26, 2023

First Posted (Actual)

August 1, 2023

Study Record Updates

Last Update Posted (Actual)

September 8, 2023

Last Update Submitted That Met QC Criteria

September 5, 2023

Last Verified

September 1, 2023

More Information

Terms related to this study

Keywords

Other Study ID Numbers

  • UNIVERSITI MALAYA
  • UMG013E-2023 (Other Grant/Funding Number: UNIVERSITY GRANT, UNIVERSITI MALAYA)

Plan for Individual participant data (IPD)

Plan to Share Individual Participant Data (IPD)?

NO

Drug and device information, study documents

Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated drug product

No

Studies a U.S. FDA-regulated device product

No

This information was retrieved directly from the website clinicaltrials.gov without any changes. If you have any requests to change, remove or update your study details, please contact register@clinicaltrials.gov. As soon as a change is implemented on clinicaltrials.gov, this will be updated automatically on our website as well.

Clinical Trials on Orthodontic Retention

Clinical Trials on Thermoformed retainers

Search Similar Trials

Sponsors and Collaborators

Medical Conditions

Drug Interventions

CROs by country

CROs in Australia

Conditions

Rare Diseases

Drug Interventions

Dietary Supplements

Sponsor/Collaborators

Locations

Subscribe